Anti-SLAPP Motions in California Employment Cases: When They Work

Rarely. California’s anti-SLAPP statute has no exception for discrimination or retaliation claims under Wilson v. Cable News Network, Inc. (2019). But an employer can move to strike a claim only when the act the employee sues over is itself protected speech or petitioning, or conduct furthering the employer’s speech on a public issue, and ordinary personnel decisions usually aren’t. When the motion fits, it can end part of a case early with a fee award. A frivolous motion costs the employer the employee’s fees.

What is an anti-SLAPP motion?

A special motion to strike claims that target speech or petitioning. Under Code of Civil Procedure section 425.16(b)(1), “A cause of action against a person arising from any act of that person in furtherance of the person’s right of petition or free speech under the United States Constitution or the California Constitution in connection with a public issue shall be subject to a special motion to strike,” unless the plaintiff shows a probability of prevailing.

Courts take it in two steps. First, the employer has to show that the challenged claim arises from protected activity. If it does, the employee has to show the claim has at least minimal merit, with evidence. A claim that fails the second step is struck.

The motion comes with procedural effects that matter to an employer. It may be filed “within 60 days of the service of the complaint” or later with the court’s permission, according to subdivision (f). Filing it stays discovery under subdivision (g), unless the court orders specific discovery for good cause. And the order granting or denying it is appealable.

Can an employer use it against a discrimination or retaliation claim?

Yes, but only in a narrow set of cases. In Wilson v. Cable News Network, Inc. (2019) 7 Cal.5th 871, a longtime CNN producer alleged he was denied promotions, given menial assignments, and fired for discriminatory and retaliatory reasons. The Court of Appeal had held those claims arose from the alleged discrimination and retaliation, not from protected activity. The Supreme Court disagreed: “The statute contains no exception for discrimination or retaliation claims,” according to the opinion.

The court also rejected the idea that an allegation of bad motive takes a claim out of the statute. It held that “the plaintiff’s allegations about the defendant’s invidious motives will not shield the claim from the same preliminary screening for minimal merit that would apply to any other claim arising from protected activity.” The focus is on what the employer did, not why the employee says it did it.

That doesn’t open the door to routine motions. The court said “The anti-SLAPP statute does not apply simply because an employer protests that its personnel decisions followed, or were communicated through, speech or petitioning activity.” The employer has to show the adverse action itself furthers its own speech or petitioning. “Cases that fit that description are the exception, not the rule,” the court wrote.

Why did CNN’s motion get past the first step?

Because CNN is a news organization and the firing enforced its journalistic standards. CNN fired the producer after an editor flagged passages in his draft story that looked similar to another outlet’s published story. The court observed that “Plagiarism is universally recognized as a serious breach of journalistic ethics,” and reasoned that disciplining an employee for it furthers a news organization’s editorial control, according to Wilson.

The win was limited to the termination. CNN’s own evidence showed it didn’t know about the possible plagiarism until a few weeks before the firing. So the court held that “CNN has thus carried its first-step burden only insofar as Wilson’s employment-related claims arise from his termination.” The claims based on missed promotions and assignments would go forward “even if the termination-specific claims are stricken,” according to the opinion, and the court sent the termination claims back to the Court of Appeal to decide whether they had minimal merit.

For most employers, the lesson runs the other way. A manufacturer, a retailer, or a medical practice firing an employee isn’t usually exercising speech rights on a public issue by doing so. The Wilson theory depended on CNN’s role as a publisher, and it covered only the decision tied to that role.

What about defamation claims over why someone was fired?

They usually don’t qualify either. Wilson also sued over CNN’s statements to prospective employers and others that he’d plagiarized. The court held those statements weren’t made in connection with a public issue. “But absent unusual circumstances, a garden-variety employment dispute concerning a nonpublic figure will implicate no public issue,” the court explained.

Statements made in official proceedings are a different category. Section 425.16(e)(1) covers “any written or oral statement or writing made before a legislative, executive, or judicial proceeding, or any other official proceeding authorized by law.” A claim built on what the company said in a court filing or an agency response is a stronger candidate for a motion than a claim built on a reference call. The firm’s post on wrongful termination lawsuits covers the main claims that defamation counts usually accompany.

What the claim is based on Anti-SLAPP fit Source
A firing, demotion, or denied promotion Usually not protected, because the decision isn’t speech Wilson
A firing that enforces a news organization’s editorial standards Can be protected, as to that decision only Wilson
Private statements about why an employee left Usually not a public issue Wilson
Statements made in a court or agency proceeding Listed as protected activity CCP § 425.16(e)(1)
An employer’s lawsuit over an employee’s agency complaint A likely target of the employee’s own motion CCP § 425.16(e)(1), (h)

What are the risks for the employer?

Fees, in both directions. Under section 425.16(c)(1), “a prevailing defendant on a special motion to strike shall be entitled to recover that defendant’s attorney’s fees and costs.” But if the court finds the motion “is frivolous or is solely intended to cause unnecessary delay,” it shall award the plaintiff’s costs and reasonable fees. A weak motion in an employment case invites exactly that finding.

Delay is the second risk. A stayed case still accrues fees on the employee’s side, and a FEHA plaintiff who prevails may recover them in the court’s discretion. An appeal from an order on the motion can push trial out further. That delay can help an employer that wants time, but it isn’t free, and it rarely changes the merits.

The statute also cuts against employers who sue. It treats a cross-defendant as a defendant under subdivision (h). An employer that sues or cross-complains against a former employee over a CRD complaint, a lawsuit, or testimony is suing over petitioning activity, and should expect a motion with fees attached. The firm’s post on CRD complaints and right-to-sue notices covers how those agency filings work.

When an anti-SLAPP motion may fit

  1. Preserve the personnel file, the decision documents, payroll records, and the emails and texts among the managers involved, plus anything showing why the decision was made and when.
  2. Calendar the 60-day window from service of the complaint along with the response deadline, and check for an arbitration agreement and an employment practices liability (EPLI) policy with notice terms.
  3. Identify the decision-makers and the reasons each gave at the time, and stop any further action involving the employee that could look like retaliation.
  4. Sort the complaint’s allegations by what each claim rests on, separating the employment decisions from any statements made in court, in agency filings, or in public.
  5. Get legal advice on whether the motion fits before filing it, since a frivolous motion shifts the employee’s fees to the company.

Most employment complaints are better answered with a demurrer, an arbitration motion, or summary judgment. More on defending employment lawsuits in California is on the firm’s employment defense page.

Anti-SLAPP questions employers ask

Does filing an anti-SLAPP motion stop discovery?

Yes, as a rule. Subdivision (g) says “All discovery proceedings in the action shall be stayed upon the filing of a notice of motion.” But the court can allow specific discovery for good cause, and Wilson noted that when an employer relies on evidence of its own motives, an employee’s request for discovery on those motives will often be justified.

If we win, does the employee pay our fees?

Section 425.16(c)(1) says a prevailing defendant “shall be entitled” to its fees and costs on the motion. When a motion succeeds only in part, the fee award can be reduced to match. In Wilson, the court held only that CNN met the first step as to the termination claims. And the fee right runs only to a defendant who prevails on the motion, so a motion that’s denied doesn’t produce a fee award for the company.

Can a motion strike only part of a claim?

Yes. Wilson applied the statute to the parts of each cause of action based on the termination, leaving the parts based on promotions and assignments in place. An employer can target the protected allegations within a claim without having to show the whole claim rests on protected activity.

Is a garden-variety termination ever a matter of public interest?

Rarely. Wilson said some people may be so prominent that any discussion of them concerns a public issue, but an ordinary employment dispute with a nonpublic figure doesn’t. A company’s internal discipline of a line employee won’t usually qualify.

If your company is weighing an anti-SLAPP motion

If your company has been sued over an employment decision and the complaint relies on statements the company made, what each claim rests on usually decides whether a motion to strike is real. Rosenberger + Kawabata represents employers defending employment lawsuits and claims through its business litigation practice, including claims involving discrimination and retaliation tied to company speech. Contact Rosenberger + Kawabata online for a confidential consultation, or call (310) 894-6921.

Sources

The statute is Code of Civil Procedure section 425.16. The case is Wilson v. Cable News Network, Inc. (2019) 7 Cal.5th 871.

This post is general information about California and federal employment law as of November 7, 2026. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Employment statutes, regulations, and court decisions change often, and the outcome of any claim depends on its facts. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes.

← Back to Blog

Let’s Talk.