Rosenberger + Kawabata represents businesses facing Telephone Consumer Protection Act demand letters and lawsuits, including proposed class actions. Our California TCPA defense practice handles claims over marketing texts, prerecorded and AI-voice calls, collection calls, and do-not-call or opt-out requests a company allegedly ignored.
TCPA defense is part of our business litigation practice. Our lawyers read the calling records themselves, write and argue the motions, and stay on the case through resolution.
California Telephone Solicitation Laws and CIPA Alongside TCPA Claims
The TCPA drives most of the exposure. Under 47 U.S.C. § 227(b)(3), a plaintiff can recover $500 per violation, and a court may increase that to $1,500 if the violation was willful or knowing. A Do Not Call claim under § 227(c)(5) requires more than one call within 12 months. California complaints often add state claims to the federal count, and each one needs its own answer.
California’s Do Not Call statute. Business and Professions Code § 17590 and the sections that follow adopt the National Do Not Call Registry as California’s list and cover wireless numbers by name. Consent buried in a contract of adhesion doesn’t count, and a stop request binds every entity that shares the brand name. The private remedy is narrow: a small claims injunction, then a penalty of up to $1,000 only if calls continue after the order is served. California also restricts text-message advertising under § 17538.41 and recorded-message dialers under Public Utilities Code §§ 2872 and 2874. Our map of California telemarketing and text laws covers each rule.
The California Invasion of Privacy Act. CIPA is the count that changes the math. Penal Code § 632.7 bars recording a call involving a cell or cordless phone without every party’s consent, and the California Supreme Court held in Smith v. LoanMe, Inc. (2021) 11 Cal.5th 183 that the statute applies to the parties to a call, not only to eavesdroppers. Penal Code § 637.2 sets damages at $5,000 per violation or three times actual damages, whichever is greater. An out-of-state call center isn’t exempt: Kearney v. Salomon Smith Barney, Inc. (2006) 39 Cal.4th 95 applied California law to calls with California clients. The defense usually depends on whether a recording disclosure played at the start of each call and whether the company can prove it. We explain the details in our post on CIPA claims in TCPA suits.
TCPA Defense in the Ninth Circuit and California Federal Courts
A TCPA case can be filed in state or federal court. A company sued in state court usually has 30 days after service to decide whether to remove, and that choice brings federal class-action rules and Ninth Circuit precedent into play. All four federal districts in California follow that precedent, and several decisions shape how we defend cases there.
The Ninth Circuit has treated a text message as a call under the TCPA since Satterfield v. Simon & Schuster, Inc. (9th Cir. 2009), and it held in Van Patten v. Vertical Fitness Group (9th Cir. 2017) that the scope of consent depends on the context in which the consumer gave the number, and it affirmed summary judgment for the defendants. In Facebook, Inc. v. Duguid (2021), the Supreme Court reversed the Ninth Circuit and held that an autodialer must have the capacity to use a random or sequential number generator, which ended many autodialer claims against list-based texting platforms. In McLaughlin Chiropractic Associates v. McKesson Corp. (2025), another case from the Ninth Circuit, the Supreme Court held that district courts aren’t bound by the FCC’s interpretations of the statute.
Recent decisions cut both ways. In Wakefield v. ViSalus, Inc. (9th Cir. 2022), the court sent a $925 million award back to the trial court and held that aggregate statutory damages can be reduced when they become so severe that they violate due process. In Howard v. Republican National Committee (9th Cir. 2026), it held that a text with an attached video, which played only when the recipient tapped it, didn’t violate the prerecorded-voice provisions. But Coffey v. Fast Easy Offer, LLC (9th Cir. 2026) revived a claim over texts offering to buy the plaintiff’s home, holding that the messages were adequately pleaded as telephone solicitations. And this fall, courts in the Central and Eastern Districts declined to follow the Seventh Circuit’s ruling that texts aren’t calls under the Do Not Call provision, as we discuss in our post on California courts and Steidinger. The Ninth Circuit hasn’t decided that question.
Rosenthal Act Overlap for Collection Calls
Collection calls to Californians raise claims under three statutes at once. The federal Fair Debt Collection Practices Act generally reaches only third-party collectors. California’s Rosenthal Fair Debt Collection Practices Act goes further: Civil Code § 1788.2 defines a debt collector to include a creditor collecting its own accounts, § 1788.11 bars calls repeated often enough to harass, and § 1788.17 imports most of the federal statute’s conduct rules. Under § 1788.30, a willful and knowing violation adds a penalty of $100 to $1,000 to actual damages, and the statute excuses a violation that occurred despite procedures reasonably adapted to avoid it.
In a collection robocall case, the TCPA count usually carries the real exposure because it counts every call. Consent often comes from the original account application, and Do Not Call rules generally don’t apply because collection calls aren’t sales calls. The defense starts with the application that shows where the number came from, the dialer’s call counts per person and per debt, and the date each revocation arrived. Our post on collection calls under federal and California law walks through the limits.
The FCC’s 2025 Opt-Out Rules and the November 2026 Changes
Since April 11, 2025, the FCC’s rules have let a consumer revoke consent to robocalls and robotexts by any reasonable method, and standard replies such as STOP count automatically. Companies must honor a revocation within ten business days. A broader “revoke all” rule, which would have made one opt-out stop every message from a sender, was delayed repeatedly and never took effect.
The FCC changed course in an order adopted on September 30, 2026. The new rules take effect November 25, 2026. A company may designate one exclusive opt-out method if every call or text discloses it, and an opt-out from informational messages can be limited to that category. The ten-business-day deadline stays, though the FCC has proposed cutting it to seven. Claims over ignored opt-outs are common, and the opt-out logs are usually central evidence in them. Our post on the FCC’s 2026 opt-out order lists the changes companies should make now.
From Demand Letter to Lawsuit to Class Action
The demand letter. Many TCPA disputes start with a letter from a plaintiff’s lawyer asking for payment by a deadline. A demand letter isn’t a lawsuit, and nothing in the statute requires a company to pay by the date it sets. The first weeks should go to testing the claim: whether the calls were the company’s own, whether consent records exist for the number, and whether a payment would actually end the matter. See our guide to answering a TCPA demand letter.
The individual lawsuit. Once a complaint is served, the early decisions matter most. We evaluate removal, pleading defects that support a motion to dismiss, arbitration clauses in the customer’s terms, and the consent evidence that might support early summary judgment.
The class action. The TCPA’s per-call damages are why these cases become class actions. The central fight is usually certification under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23, and consent is often where it is won or lost: if proving consent requires examining each class member’s sign-up, individual questions can defeat certification. Any class settlement needs court approval after notice and a fairness hearing. Our post on TCPA class action defense and settlement covers the structure.
TCPA Defense FAQs
What should a business do after receiving a TCPA demand?
A business receiving a TCPA demand should preserve the records needed to evaluate the allegations before responding. The Telephone Consumer Protection Act, 47 U.S.C. § 227, regulates prerecorded and autodialed calls and texts and creates separate claims for telephone solicitations to numbers on the Do Not Call Registry, so the defense depends on which provision the demand invokes. Preserve call and text logs, the original message content, and the consent records for the disputed numbers. Keep opt-out histories and Do Not Call scrub records, including the dates of the Registry versions used. If a vendor ran the campaign, ask it in writing to preserve its records, and pull the contract. Don’t overwrite campaign settings or replace old scripts while investigating. Counsel should review the demand against those materials before the company concedes any facts or discusses settlement.
What damages can a TCPA plaintiff recover?
The TCPA sets statutory damages of $500 per violation, and a court may increase that to as much as $1,500 per violation if it finds the violation willful or knowing, under 47 U.S.C. § 227(b)(3). The plaintiff doesn’t need to prove actual losses. Because damages run per call or text, a single campaign sent to a large list can produce class-wide exposure in the millions. That number is not the end of the analysis. The Ninth Circuit held in Wakefield v. ViSalus, Inc. that aggregate statutory damages can be reduced when they become so severe that they violate due process. Consent defenses can also defeat class certification, which shrinks the case back to one plaintiff. In California, a call-recording claim under Penal Code § 637.2 adds $5,000 per violation, so a complaint that pairs both counts deserves early attention to the recording disclosures.
Does California’s Do Not Call law allow per-call damages?
No. A consumer can seek a small claims injunction under Business and Professions Code § 17593, and a penalty of up to $1,000 only if calls continue after the order is served. Public prosecutors can seek larger civil penalties. For most companies, the per-call exposure still comes from the federal TCPA.
Can a company be sued in California for recording sales calls?
Yes. Penal Code § 632.7 requires every party’s consent to record a call involving a cell or cordless phone, and it applies to companies recording their own calls. A clear disclosure at the start of each call, and proof that it played, is the main defense.
Does using a texting vendor eliminate TCPA exposure?
No. A vendor’s involvement doesn’t by itself resolve a company’s responsibility for the communications. We review the vendor relationship and the conduct alleged, along with the records supporting any consent defense. Contractual claims against the vendor may require separate analysis.
Does the firm represent TCPA plaintiffs?
No. Our TCPA practice represents businesses defending claims. The firm’s separate investment fraud and FINRA arbitration practices represent investors in disputes concerning their investments.
TCPA Defense Guides for Businesses
These posts from the firm’s blog cover the questions that come up most often in TCPA defense. All TCPA posts are listed on the blog.
Demand letters and first steps
- TCPA Demand Letters: How a Business Evaluates and Answers One
- Sued Under the TCPA? A Business’s First Steps in California
- TCPA Damages Exposure: How Courts Count It, and Where to Push Back
Class actions
- TCPA Class Actions: What Defendants Should Know About Settlement
- TCPA Class Certification: Using Consent to Defeat Predominance
- Can a TCPA Class Action Be Forced Into Arbitration?
- TCPA Motion to Dismiss: Pleading Defects Beyond the Autodialer
Consent and opt-outs
- TCPA Scope of Consent: Does a Phone Number Cover Every Call or Text?
- Texts After a STOP Reply: How Businesses Get Sued, and How to Avoid It
- The FCC’s 2026 Opt-Out Order: What Businesses That Text Must Change
Do Not Call and quiet hours
- Do Not Call Lawsuits: The Defenses Available to Businesses
- Quiet-Hours TCPA Claims: Defenses for Businesses That Text
- California Federal Courts Decline to Follow Steidinger on Texts
Vendors and insurance
- When Is a Seller Liable for a Vendor’s TCPA Calls?
- TCPA Vendor Contracts: Indemnity, Consent Warranties, and Audits
- Does Business Insurance Cover TCPA Claims in California?
California law
- California Telemarketing and Text Laws: A Map for Businesses
- Recording Sales Calls in California: CIPA Claims in TCPA Suits
Discuss a TCPA Defense Matter
If your company has received a demand or been sued over calls or texts, contact Rosenberger + Kawabata for a confidential consultation. Call (310) 894-6921.