Refiled TCPA Lawsuits: Making the Plaintiff Pay Under Rule 41(d)
“If a plaintiff who previously dismissed an action in any court files an action based on or including the same claim against the same defendant,” a federal court may order the plaintiff to pay the costs of the first case and stay the new one until it does, under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 41(d). TCPA plaintiffs dismiss and refile more than most, often to change courts or judges. Rule 41(d) is a defendant’s tool for making that move cost something, though whether attorney’s fees come with it depends on the circuit.
Why do TCPA plaintiffs dismiss and refile?
Usually to get a better forum or a cleaner complaint. A plaintiff facing a motion to compel arbitration, a motion to dismiss with a strong argument, or an unfavorable judge may drop the case before the defendant answers and file again somewhere else. Some refile in state court to avoid federal precedent. Others add a new defendant or a new theory and start over.
Rule 41(a)(1) makes that easy at the start of a case. A plaintiff can dismiss without a court order by filing “a notice of dismissal before the opposing party serves either an answer or a motion for summary judgment,” according to Rule 41(a)(1)(A)(i). The dismissal is normally without prejudice, so the claim survives.
There’s one built-in limit. If the plaintiff “previously dismissed any federal- or state-court action based on or including the same claim, a notice of dismissal operates as an adjudication on the merits,” under Rule 41(a)(1)(B). That’s the two-dismissal rule. A second voluntary dismissal of the same claim by notice ends it for good.
What does Rule 41(d) let a defendant recover?
The costs of the first case, and a stay of the second until they’re paid. The rule says the court “may order the plaintiff to pay all or part of the costs of that previous action” and “may stay the proceedings until the plaintiff has complied,” according to Rule 41(d). Both are discretionary. The defendant has to show that the new case is based on or includes the same claim against the same defendant.
The stay is often worth more than the money. A stay pending payment stops discovery and motion practice cold, and it puts the burden on the plaintiff to decide whether the refiled case is worth the price of admission. For an individual TCPA plaintiff, that’s a real decision.
Can a defendant recover attorney’s fees under Rule 41(d)?
It depends on the circuit, and in the Ninth Circuit the answer for most TCPA cases is likely no. The rule doesn’t define “costs,” and the federal courts of appeals have split over whether fees are included.
The Ninth Circuit took up the question in August 2026. In ThermoLife International, LLC v. BPI Sports, LLC, No. 23-15903, a divided panel held “that attorney’s fees may be recovered as part of costs under Rule 41(d) if the statute underlying the litigation provides for the award of attorneys’ fees.” The underlying claim there was under the Lanham Act, which allows fees in exceptional cases, so the court affirmed the fee award, with a limited remand to fix a computational error.
The panel described the split. The court stated that “The Second, Eighth, and Tenth Circuit have ruled that attorney’s fees are available as part of costs under Rule 41(d) in the discretion of the court,” and that “The Sixth Circuit stands alone in holding that attorney’s fees are not recoverable as costs under Rule 41(d),” according to the ThermoLife opinion. The opinion listed four other circuits, starting with the Seventh, that tie fees to the underlying statute, and the Ninth Circuit joined them.
That matters for TCPA defendants. The TCPA’s private rights of action in 47 U.S.C. § 227(b)(3) and (c)(5) provide for damages and injunctions, not for attorney’s fees to either side. Under ThermoLife’s test, a defendant in the Ninth Circuit generally can’t recover fees under Rule 41(d) when the dismissed case pleaded only TCPA claims. It can still recover ordinary costs and seek a stay.
The court left one door open. The panel didn’t decide “whether attorney’s fees may be available if a” court finds that a plaintiff “acted in bad faith, vexatiously, wantonly, or for oppressive reasons,” according to ThermoLife. A defendant with evidence of a forum-shopping pattern can still make that argument in the Ninth Circuit, though no binding authority there supports it yet.
How Rule 41(d) fits with a TCPA defense
| Situation | Rule | What the defendant can seek | Practical value |
|---|---|---|---|
| Plaintiff dismisses by notice and refiles the same claim | Rule 41(d) | Costs of the first case and a stay until paid | High, because the stay halts the new case |
| Second voluntary dismissal of the same claim by notice | Rule 41(a)(1)(B) | Treat the dismissal as an adjudication on the merits | Ends the claim |
| Refiled TCPA case in the Ninth Circuit | Rule 41(d), as read in ThermoLife | Costs, but generally not fees, since the TCPA doesn’t provide for fees | Moderate |
| Refiled case with evidence of bad faith | Inherent authority, and an open question under Rule 41(d) in the Ninth Circuit | Fees on a specific bad-faith finding | Depends on the record |
| Underlying exposure in the refiled case | 47 U.S.C. § 227 | Defend on the merits: up to $500 per violation, or up to $1,500 if willful or knowing | Unchanged by Rule 41(d) |
What should a defendant do when a dismissed TCPA case comes back?
Move quickly, and build the record of the first case before asking. A Rule 41(d) motion is strongest when it lays out the overlap point by point: the same calls or texts, the same numbers, the same defendant, and the same statutory claims. Line up the two complaints side by side.
Two practical points help. First, keep a clean record of the costs incurred in the first case, separated from fees, because costs are what every circuit allows. Second, consider asking for the stay even when the cost amount is small. A plaintiff who refiled to escape a judge or a pending motion often won’t pay to continue, and a stayed case that sits idle tends to end on its own.
Defendants should also watch for refiling in state court. Rule 41(d) applies when the new action is filed in federal court. If the refiled case lands in state court, the defendant should look at removal and at the state’s own rules. The TCPA removal post covers when moving the case back to federal court helps. Repeat filers raise their own issues, covered in the serial TCPA plaintiffs post. For an overview of how these cases are defended, see the firm’s TCPA class action defense page.
When a dismissed TCPA claim is refiled
- Keep the litigation hold from the first case in place, covering the call and text logs, the dialer or platform data, and the consent records for the numbers in both complaints.
- Pull the opt-out and internal do-not-call history for those numbers, with dates, so nothing gets lost between the two cases.
- Retrieve the Do Not Call Registry scrub records and the Registry version dates used for each contact.
- Collect the vendor and lead-source contracts, the scripts, and any recorded or AI-voice messages, along with the cost records from the first case.
- Have counsel compare the two complaints and decide on a Rule 41(d) motion before responding to the new complaint or discussing settlement.
Questions about refiled TCPA cases
Can a TCPA plaintiff dismiss a case and file it again?
Usually, yes. A plaintiff can dismiss without a court order before the defendant serves an answer or a summary judgment motion, and that first dismissal is normally without prejudice. But a second voluntary dismissal of the same claim by notice operates as an adjudication on the merits. And if the plaintiff refiles in federal court, Rule 41(d) lets the court order costs and stay the new case.
Does Rule 41(d) apply if the plaintiff refiles in a different court?
The rule applies when the first case was dismissed “in any court,” under Rule 41(d), and the new action is filed in federal court against the same defendant on the same claim. The earlier case could have been in state or federal court. If the refiled case is in state court, Rule 41(d) doesn’t govern it, and the defendant should look at removal and state procedure instead.
Are attorney’s fees part of Rule 41(d) costs in California federal courts?
Only if the statute behind the dismissed case provides for fees, under the Ninth Circuit’s August 2026 decision in ThermoLife. The TCPA’s private rights of action don’t provide for attorney’s fees, so a defendant in a refiled TCPA case in California federal court will generally recover costs but not fees. The court left open whether bad faith could support fees.
Is the stay under Rule 41(d) automatic?
No. Both the cost award and the stay are discretionary, so the defendant has to ask for them and show the overlap between the two cases. Courts look at whether the new case is based on or includes the same claim against the same defendant. Evidence that the plaintiff refiled to avoid a ruling or a judge makes the request stronger.
If a dismissed TCPA claim is back
If your company has been sued again on a TCPA claim the plaintiff already dismissed, the record of the first case usually decides how much pressure Rule 41(d) can put on the plaintiff. Rosenberger + Kawabata represents businesses defending TCPA lawsuits and class actions through its business litigation practice, including claims refiled after a voluntary dismissal. Contact Rosenberger + Kawabata online for a confidential consultation, or call (310) 894-6921.
Sources
The rule is Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 41. The Ninth Circuit’s decision is ThermoLife International, LLC v. BPI Sports, LLC, No. 23-15903 (9th Cir. Aug. 18, 2026). The TCPA’s private rights of action are in 47 U.S.C. § 227.
This post is general information about the Telephone Consumer Protection Act and related laws as of September 6, 2026. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Courts and the FCC change the rules in this area often, and the outcome of any claim depends on its facts. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes.