Issue Classes in TCPA Cases: How Rule 23(c)(4) Is Used and Defended

When consent varies from one call recipient to the next, a TCPA plaintiff often can’t certify a full damages class. The fallback is an issue class: a request to certify only the questions that are common, such as whether a dialer used a prerecorded voice or whether a vendor called on the defendant’s behalf, and leave the rest for later. Federal Rule 23(c)(4) allows that only when appropriate, and recent appellate rulings make that a real hurdle. A defendant that shows how much individual work would remain usually has the stronger argument.

What is an issue class?

A class certified for particular questions instead of whole claims. Rule 23(c)(4) provides: “When appropriate, an action may be brought or maintained as a class action with respect to particular issues,” under Fed. R. Civ. P. 23(c)(4). If the issue class wins, each class member still has to prove the remaining elements of a claim in later proceedings, or the parties settle.

In a TCPA case, the common issues plaintiffs propose tend to be about the defendant’s conduct: the technology used to place the calls, whether the calls were telemarketing, whether a lead vendor or call center acted as the defendant’s agent, or whether a written consent form met the regulation’s requirements. The individual issues are usually about the recipients: whether each one consented, whether consent was revoked, whether the number was reassigned, and whether the recipient was the subscriber or customary user of the phone.

When can a court certify an issue class?

Most circuits allow it even when the claim as a whole fails predominance, but the issue itself has to qualify. In Jacks v. DirectSat USA, LLC, decided October 3, 2024, the Seventh Circuit stated the question directly: “must a party show that common issues predominate in the resolution of the entire claim, or is it enough that common issues predominate as to each issue to be certified?”

The court answered: “Agreeing with the Second, Third, Fourth, Sixth, and Ninth Circuits, we hold that, as part of satisfying its burden under Rule 23, a party seeking certification of an issue class under Rule 23(c)(4) must show that common questions predominate in the resolution of the specific issue or issues that are the subject of the certification motion.” The court also noted that the Fifth Circuit has taken a narrower view, limiting issue classes to cases where the cause of action as a whole satisfies predominance, and that the D.C. Circuit has taken a middle position.

The Third Circuit framed the test as three questions in Russell v. Educational Commission for Foreign Medical Graduates (2021). The court first asks whether the proposed issue class meets Rule 23(a). Then: “Second, does the proposed issue class fit within one of Rule 23(b)’s categories?” Only then does the court ask whether issue certification is appropriate. Because the district court there skipped steps, the Third Circuit vacated the issue-class certification and sent the case back.

Why is superiority the defendant’s best argument?

Because an issue class has to make the case easier to resolve, not just shorter at trial. In Jacks, the Seventh Circuit held that “in addition to demonstrating that common questions predominate as to each issue to be certified, a party seeking certification under Rule 23(c)(4) must show that certifying the proposed issues would be the most practical and efficient way to resolve the litigation.”

The court then affirmed decertification of a wage-and-hour issue class on that ground. “Thus, even if the fourteen certified issues were answered, doing so would not materially advance Plaintiffs’ claims given the magnitude of what remains,” the court wrote, according to Jacks. It concluded that “a class action, as currently certified, is not a superior device to resolve this controversy.”

That reasoning fits TCPA cases well. If a jury decides that a vendor’s calls used a prerecorded voice, the case still has to answer, for every recipient, whether that person agreed to be called, whether that agreement was revoked, and whether the number belonged to that person at the time. When consent records are spread across lead sources, opt-in pages, and customer accounts, those follow-on questions are the case. The common issue is a small part of it.

How should a defendant oppose a TCPA issue class?

By making the remaining individual work concrete. A general argument that consent is individual won’t carry much weight in a circuit that permits issue classes. A declaration that maps the consent sources, shows how many recipients came from each, and explains what evidence each source would require is what turns the Seventh Circuit’s concern about the work that remains into a record the court can rely on.

Several other points tend to matter:

The proposed issue has to be separable. An issue such as whether a vendor acted as the defendant’s agent may depend on which vendor, which campaign, and which contract. If the answer differs by vendor, the issue isn’t common at all.

The issue class has to fit a Rule 23(b) category. Under Russell, a plaintiff seeking damages still has to show how the issue class fits Rule 23(b), and in most TCPA cases that means Rule 23(b)(3).

The follow-on proceedings have to be workable. A plaintiff proposing an issue class should explain how thousands of individual consent determinations would be handled afterward. If the plan is silent or vague, that’s a gap to press.

The consent defense to class certification post covers how individualized consent defeats predominance in a full Rule 23(b)(3) class. For how these certification fights fit into a broader defense, see the firm’s TCPA class action defense page.

How does an issue class change settlement pressure?

It can increase it, and that’s the practical risk. A certified issue class lets a plaintiff try the defendant’s conduct once, with the whole class behind it, even if each class member’s recovery still depends on later proof. A defendant that loses the common issue faces a long tail of individual claims with the conduct question already decided.

That’s a reason to fight the certification motion on the record, not to assume the follow-on proceedings will never happen. It’s also a reason to consider a Rule 23(f) petition when a court certifies an issue class over a strong superiority objection. The Rule 23(f) appeals post covers that process.

Proposed common issue Why plaintiffs propose it Individual questions left over Defense focus
Whether calls used a prerecorded or artificial voice Depends on the defendant’s dialing technology Consent, revocation, reassigned numbers Superiority under Rule 23(b)(3)
Whether a vendor called as the defendant’s agent Depends on contracts and control Which vendor called whom, and under what consent Whether the answer differs by vendor
Whether a consent form met the written-consent rule Depends on one form’s wording Who saw which form version, and when Version history of the form
Damages under the TCPA Up to $500 per violation, or up to $1,500 if willful or knowing Number of violations per recipient Whether issue resolution advances the case

When an issue class motion is filed

  1. Confirm the litigation hold covers call and text logs, dialer and platform data, and the consent records for the putative class.
  2. Pull the opt-out and internal do-not-call logs, with dates, so revocation can be shown recipient by recipient.
  3. Collect the Do Not Call Registry scrub records and the version dates used for the campaign.
  4. Gather the vendor and lead-source contracts and scripts, plus any recorded or AI-voice message files, sorted by vendor and campaign.
  5. Work with counsel on a declaration that maps the individual issues before the opposition is due, and before any settlement discussion.

Questions about TCPA issue classes

Can a TCPA plaintiff certify an issue class after a full class is denied?

It’s possible in most circuits. Six federal circuits, including the Seventh and the Ninth, allow an issue class when common questions predominate within the issue itself, even if they don’t predominate for the claim as a whole. But the plaintiff still has to satisfy Rule 23(a), fit the issue class within Rule 23(b), and show that certifying the issue is the most practical and efficient way to resolve the case.

What happens after an issue class is decided?

The rest of each class member’s claim still has to be resolved. In a TCPA case, that usually means individual proof of consent and number ownership, along with the count of calls or texts. Courts weighing superiority look at how much of that follow-on work would remain, which is why the defendant’s showing on individual issues matters so much.

Is an issue class easier to defeat in the Fifth Circuit?

The Fifth Circuit has taken a narrower view than most circuits, limiting issue classes to cases where the cause of action as a whole satisfies predominance. A defendant in a Texas, Louisiana, or Mississippi federal court can press that standard. Elsewhere, the stronger argument is usually superiority, because most circuits permit issue classes when the issue itself is common.

Can a defendant appeal an issue class certification?

A defendant can petition the court of appeals for permission to appeal an order granting class certification under Rule 23(f). The court of appeals decides whether to hear the appeal, so the petition is discretionary. The Third Circuit’s Russell decision vacated an issue-class certification, which shows that appellate courts will review these orders when the district court’s analysis is incomplete.

Defending against an issue class

If your company faces a motion to certify an issue class in a TCPA case, the consent records and how they vary across recipients usually decide the case. Rosenberger + Kawabata represents businesses defending TCPA lawsuits and class actions through its business litigation practice, including claims involving class certification of particular issues. Contact Rosenberger + Kawabata online for a confidential consultation, or call (310) 894-6921.

Sources

The rule is Fed. R. Civ. P. 23. The Seventh Circuit’s decision is Jacks v. DirectSat USA, LLC, 118 F.4th 888 (7th Cir. 2024), and the Third Circuit’s is Russell v. Educational Commission for Foreign Medical Graduates, 15 F.4th 259 (3d Cir. 2021). The federal statute is 47 U.S.C. § 227.

This post is general information about the Telephone Consumer Protection Act and related laws as of September 16, 2026. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Courts and the FCC change the rules in this area often, and the outcome of any claim depends on its facts. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes.

← Back to Blog

Let’s Talk.