Hossfeld v. Allstate: No Vicarious TCPA Liability Up the Chain
A company that hires a telemarketing vendor can usually be sued when that vendor ignores a Do Not Call request. On June 24, 2026, the Seventh Circuit drew a line. In Hossfeld v. Allstate Insurance Co., the court held that Allstate wasn’t liable for calls placed by a telemarketer two layers down a chain it had never heard of, because nobody gave that caller authority to act for Allstate. For a business that buys leads or outsources calling, the decision is a map to a real defense.
What the Seventh Circuit held in Hossfeld v. Allstate
The court reversed a plaintiff’s win and sent the case back with instructions to enter judgment for the company. Writing for a panel that also included Judges Rovner and Sykes, Judge St. Eve summed up the result: “Hossfeld failed to show Allstate is liable for Atlantic’s calls under any theory of agency law,” according to the opinion in Nos. 25-1518 and 25-1672.
The chain the court had to untangle ran like this. Two Allstate insurance agents hired a telemarketing company called Transfer Kings. Transfer Kings then subcontracted the actual calling to a second company called Atlantic. It never told the agents it had done so. According to the opinion, “Neither Allstate nor its insurance agents knew that Atlantic existed and was marketing Allstate insurance until after Hossfeld filed his lawsuit.” Atlantic placed twelve calls to Robert Hossfeld between November 2020 and February 2021, even though his number had sat on Allstate’s internal do-not-call list, the company’s own roster of people it has agreed not to call, since July 2020.
The private claim comes from the TCPA’s Do Not Call provision, which lets a person sue after “more than one telephone call within any 12-month period by or on behalf of the same entity,” under 47 U.S.C. § 227(c)(5). The whole case turned on four words: “on behalf of.” The district court had said Atlantic’s calls counted and entered summary judgment for Hossfeld, with treble damages on top. The Seventh Circuit disagreed on both points.
Why the calls didn’t travel up the chain to Allstate
Agency law is the set of rules that decide when one company answers for another’s conduct. A principal is liable for an agent’s act when the agent had authority to act, or when the principal later ratified what the agent did. A subagent is someone an agent brings in to help with the principal’s work, and a subagent’s acts can reach the principal too. That’s the doctrine the firm walks through in when a seller answers for a vendor’s calls.
But the chain only holds if every link is authorized. The court’s key move was to insist on authority at each handoff: “there must be appointing authority at each level to support an agency relationship between each subagent and the principal.” Hossfeld’s theory skipped a link. He pointed to Allstate’s contracts with its agents, which told the agents to make sure outside callers followed the law. Fine, the court said, maybe that let the agents hire Transfer Kings. But nothing Allstate wrote or did told Transfer Kings it could hire anyone else. The contract language wasn’t aimed at Transfer Kings, and Transfer Kings never saw it.
The court didn’t hide what was driving the result. Accepting Hossfeld’s reading would let liability run forever, the panel warned: “Adopting Hossfeld’s position would allow for seemingly infinite levels of subagency.” A company would answer for a caller it never approved, hired by a vendor it never approved, and so on with no stopping point.
There’s a burden-of-proof point buried here that matters more than the quotable lines, and it’s the part worth copying into a brief. The district court had reasoned that nothing in the record forbade Transfer Kings from subcontracting. The Seventh Circuit called that backwards. “Agency relationships are not the default,” the court wrote, so the plaintiff has to produce affirmative evidence that each appointment was authorized. Silence in the record cuts against the plaintiff, not the defendant.
What the ruling gives companies that use calling vendors
Hossfeld tried two fallback theories, and the court rejected both in ways defense counsel can use.
On apparent authority, the idea that the caller looked authorized, the court held that only the principal’s own words or conduct count. Atlantic told Hossfeld it was calling for Allstate, but that doesn’t matter: “Allstate never made those statements, nor did it instruct Atlantic to do so.” A vendor can’t manufacture your liability by announcing your name on a call you never approved.
On ratification, the theory that a company blessed the calls after the fact by keeping the benefits, the court looked at what Allstate actually did when it found out. “Allstate promptly traced the problematic calls to Transfer Kings and immediately began a thorough investigation,” and within months it barred its agents from working with either Transfer Kings or Atlantic. That response was the opposite of ratification, and the court said so: “No reasonable jury could construe Allstate’s response as a total failure to act tantamount to ratification of Atlantic’s calls.” Moving fast against a rogue vendor isn’t just good hygiene. It’s evidence.
The court also tightened the screws on treble damages, which is the number that turns a nuisance suit into a real one. The district court had said a violation is “willful” whenever the caller meant to place the call. Wrong standard, the panel held: “Volitional action is thus insufficient to trigger treble damages under the TCPA.” Willfulness takes knowing or reckless conduct, which lines the Seventh Circuit up with the Fourth and Eleventh Circuits.
| Theory of liability | What the plaintiff had to prove | What defeated it in Hossfeld |
|---|---|---|
| Subagency / actual authority | Allstate authorized Transfer Kings to appoint the caller | Allstate gave Transfer Kings no such authority, so that link never formed |
| Apparent authority | A belief traceable to Allstate’s own words or conduct | The caller’s self-introduction isn’t the principal’s own word or act |
| Ratification | Allstate knowingly kept the benefit or failed to act | Prompt investigation and a ban on the vendors, not acquiescence |
| Willful violation (treble damages) | Knowing or reckless violation, not just a deliberate call | Volitional calling isn’t enough for treble damages |
What the decision doesn’t do
This is a Seventh Circuit opinion, so it binds the federal courts in that circuit. In California and the rest of the Ninth Circuit it’s persuasive, not controlling, and a plaintiff will argue the agency facts differently. Don’t read it as a nationwide shield.
It also doesn’t erase vendor liability. Change the facts and the result changes. If a company authorizes its vendors to subcontract, or learns a sketchy telemarketer is dialing its list and shrugs, the chain reconnects and ratification comes back into play. The reason Allstate won on ratification is that it acted, fast.
And the statute still rewards companies that build real compliance before a suit lands. Section 227(c)(5) gives a defendant an affirmative defense for having “reasonable practices and procedures to effectively prevent telephone solicitations in violation of the regulations.” Exposure runs up to $500 per call, and up to $1,500 per call if a court finds the violation was willful or knowing, so the procedures that knock a case down to the base number, or out altogether, pay for themselves. Hossfeld doesn’t change any of that. It just confirms that a company can’t be charged for a caller it never let into the chain.
What to do when a vendor’s calls trigger a TCPA claim
When a demand letter or complaint shows up blaming you for a vendor’s calls, the agency chain is where the case is won or lost, and you win it with the records you preserve on day one. The firm’s page on defending TCPA class actions in California walks through how these vendor-chain cases move through state and federal court.
- Put a litigation hold on everything tied to the campaign: your contracts with the vendor, call and text logs, dialer and platform records, and the consent or lead records for those numbers.
- Map the chain. Identify every company that touched the calling, who hired whom, and what each contract said about using outside callers. The handoff you didn’t authorize is your defense.
- Pull your internal do-not-call list and the dates each number went on it, plus your written do-not-call policy and procedures.
- Gather what you did once you learned about the calls: the investigation, the emails, any decision to cut the vendor off. That record is what sank the ratification theory in Hossfeld.
- Talk to a lawyer before you respond to the demand, contact the claimant, or offer anything to settle.
Questions companies ask about vendor TCPA liability
Can we be liable for a telemarketer our vendor hired without telling us?
Not automatically. Under Hossfeld, your vendor needed authority from you to bring in that second caller, and you had to convey that authority to the vendor itself, not just to your own agents. If you never authorized the subcontract and never ratified the calls, the Seventh Circuit says liability stops before it reaches you. The facts of each chain still matter, so the contracts control a lot of the answer.
Does telling our vendors to follow the law make us liable for everyone they hire?
It shouldn’t, and that was a central point in Hossfeld. A contract clause telling your direct agents to keep outside callers compliant is aimed at those agents. It isn’t a message to companies further down the chain, and the court refused to treat it as open-ended permission for endless layers of subagents.
What’s the fastest way to kill a treble-damages demand?
Attack the willfulness standard and show what you did when you found out. After Hossfeld, a deliberate call isn’t a willful violation. The plaintiff needs knowing or reckless conduct. A documented investigation and a quick move to cut off a non-compliant vendor are strong evidence that your conduct was neither.
If your company is sued for a vendor’s calls
If your company is blamed for robocalls or Do Not Call violations placed by a lead vendor or a telemarketer down the chain, the contracts and your response to the complaints usually decide whether the calls are yours at all. Rosenberger + Kawabata represents businesses defending TCPA lawsuits and class actions through its business litigation practice, including claims involving calls placed by a lead vendor or subcontractor. Contact Rosenberger + Kawabata online for a confidential consultation, or call (310) 894-6921.
Sources
Hossfeld v. Allstate Insurance Co., Nos. 25-1518 and 25-1672 (7th Cir. June 24, 2026): Seventh Circuit opinion.
Telephone Consumer Protection Act, private right of action and treble damages: 47 U.S.C. § 227(c)(5).
This post is general information about the Telephone Consumer Protection Act and related laws as of November 10, 2026. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Courts and the FCC change the rules in this area often, and the outcome of any claim depends on its facts. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes.