Claims-Made vs. Common-Fund TCPA Settlements: A Defendant’s Guide

A claims-made settlement pays only the class members who file a claim. A common-fund settlement sets a fixed sum up front and divides it among claimants, usually with nothing returning to the defendant. For a business settling a TCPA class action, that choice often moves the real cost more than the headline number does. It also changes how hard a federal judge will look at the deal. A defendant that knows the approval rules can usually find a structure that controls cost and survives the fairness hearing.

How do claims-made and common-fund settlements differ?

Court approval under Rule 23(e) applies to either kind of deal, and they split on one question: who keeps the money that class members never claim?

In a claims-made deal, the defendant pays a set amount per valid claim, often up to a cap, and pays nothing for class members who never file. The Ninth Circuit described one such settlement in Briseño v. Henderson as a fund set up “on a claims-made basis,” and it was blunt about the result: “So little goes to the class members in a claims-made settlement, such as this one, because the redemption rate is notoriously low, especially when it involves small-ticket items.”

In a common fund, the defendant writes one check into a settlement fund, and everything comes out of that fund, from notice costs and class counsel’s fees to the claimants’ checks. Unclaimed money gets redistributed to claimants or, if that’s impractical, sent to a charity under the cy pres doctrine.

Hybrids exist too, such as a claims-made deal with a minimum payout floor. The labels matter less than the answers to three questions: what’s the most the company can pay, what’s the least, and where do the leftovers go?

Why does the structure matter so much in a TCPA case?

The Telephone Consumer Protection Act sets damages per call or text, which makes class numbers look enormous on paper. The statute allows “$500 in damages for each such violation,” and a court may raise that up to three times, or up to $1,500, if it finds the violation willful or knowing, under 47 U.S.C. § 227(b)(3).

Settlements pay the people who show up, plus fees and costs, instead of $500 for every number in the call log. That’s why the structure is where a defendant saves or loses real money.

Briseño noted that the redemption rate “shrinks even further if the settlement, as here, provides for no direct notice to class members.” TCPA classes tend to sit at the other end. The class is defined by phone numbers in the defendant’s own logs, so the parties can often find and notify most class members directly, and direct notice pushes claim rates up. A defendant shouldn’t count on consumer-product claim rates for a class it can text or mail.

Class size estimates in settlement talks usually come from the plaintiff’s data analysis, and knowing how to challenge a TCPA data expert’s number analysis can shrink the class before anyone negotiates over it. After that, run the class list, estimate a realistic claim rate for the notice plan the court will likely require, and price both structures side by side before agreeing to any number.

Which terms draw the most scrutiny at approval?

Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23(e)(2), a judge can approve a class settlement only after finding it “fair, reasonable, and adequate,” and the rule lists what the court must consider. Two of those items aim straight at structure: “the effectiveness of any proposed method of distributing relief to the class, including the method of processing class-member claims,” and “the terms of any proposed award of attorney’s fees, including timing of payment.” The 2018 amendments added that list.

In the Ninth Circuit, the starting point is In re Bluetooth Headset Products Liability Litigation (2011), which named three warning signs of collusion. The first is “when counsel receive a disproportionate distribution of the settlement, or when the class receives no monetary distribution but class counsel are amply rewarded.”

The second sign in Bluetooth is a clear sailing arrangement, where the defendant agrees not to oppose class counsel’s fee request, “providing for the payment of attorneys’ fees separate and apart from class funds.” The third is “when the parties arrange for fees not awarded to revert to defendants rather than be added to the class fund,” often called a kicker or reverter.

Until 2021, the Ninth Circuit hadn’t said whether those signs mattered when the parties settled after a class was certified. Briseño answered that. The court held that “courts must apply Bluetooth’s heightened scrutiny to post-class certification settlements,” and it reversed approval of a settlement that combined a claims-made fund, a clear sailing clause, and a kicker.

The same 2021 opinion gives defendants room, and it’s worth quoting in any approval brief: “Disproportionate fee awards, clear sailing agreements, and kicker clauses all may be elements of a good deal.” Briseño also said “nothing in this opinion suggests that courts should unnecessarily meddle in class settlements negotiated by the parties.” None of the three signs is a ban. They’re reasons for the judge to ask more questions.

Claims-made deals with separately paid fees carry the most risk under Rule 23(e)(2). When the class takes home a small share of the total, that structure trips the first warning sign almost automatically. A defendant that wants claims-made economics should expect to give something back, such as a minimum payout floor or fees measured by what the class actually receives.

Under Rule 23(e)(3), “The parties seeking approval must file a statement identifying any agreement made in connection with the proposal,” so side deals come out into the open. Any payment to drop an objection or an appeal needs court approval after a hearing under Rule 23(e)(5)(B).

Where should the unclaimed money go?

A reversion of unclaimed class money raises the same question Bluetooth asked about unawarded fees: who benefits when class members don’t claim? Defendants can propose it, but it hands objectors their best argument. Sending the leftover anywhere but back to the defendant is the safer course.

Second distributions to class members who did file are the cleanest alternative. When the leftover is too small to send out again, cy pres comes in. The Ninth Circuit held in Nachshin v. AOL, LLC (2011) that a cy pres award must fit the lawsuit and account for “the interests of the silent class members, including their geographic diversity.” In a TCPA case, that usually means a consumer-privacy or telecommunications-focused recipient with national reach, not the defendant’s favorite local charity.

Vouchers and account credits need extra care, because a court may find they’re coupons under the Class Action Fairness Act (CAFA). Under 28 U.S.C. § 1712(a), the part of class counsel’s fee tied to coupons “shall be based on the value to class members of the coupons that are redeemed.” Subsection (e) bars approval unless the court holds a hearing and makes “a written finding that, the settlement is fair, reasonable, and adequate for class members.” Credits make little sense for people who never wanted the company’s calls.

Comparing the main settlement structures

Structure What the defendant pays Where unclaimed money goes Approval risk in the Ninth Circuit
Claims-made Only valid claims, usually up to a cap, plus separately paid fees and costs Stays with the defendant Highest, above all with clear sailing and a kicker (Bluetooth, Briseño)
Common fund, non-reversionary One fixed amount that covers claims and fees plus notice and administration costs Second distribution or cy pres Lowest, since fees come out of the same fund the class shares
Common fund with reversion Fixed amount, with part of the leftover returned Part returns to the defendant Moderate to high, since the reversion invites objections
Coupon or credit Credits, with fees tied to redemption Unredeemed credits usually lapse Heightened by 28 U.S.C. § 1712 (hearing and written finding)
Individual settlement Payment to the named plaintiff only Not applicable No Rule 23(e) approval needed if no class was certified

What does CAFA require from the defendant itself?

Class counsel carries most of the approval work, but the notice under 28 U.S.C. § 1715 is the defendant’s job.

Under 28 U.S.C. § 1715(b), “Not later than 10 days after a proposed settlement of a class action is filed in court, each defendant that is participating in the proposed settlement” must serve notice on the appropriate federal official and the appropriate official in each state where a class member lives. The package includes the complaint, the settlement, and any side agreement, among other items. For most defendants, the federal official is the U.S. Attorney General. Banks and other depository institutions serve their primary federal regulator instead.

Section 1715(d) says final approval “may not be issued earlier than 90 days after the later of the dates” the officials were served. Under § 1715(e)(1), a class member can choose not to be bound by the settlement if it shows the notice was never provided. A release that some class members can walk away from isn’t what the company paid for.

Settlement administrators often handle the § 1715 mailings, but the duty stays with the defendant. Defense counsel should calendar it the day the motion for preliminary approval is filed. Preliminary approval, notice, the claims period, the 90-day CAFA wait, and the final hearing all add months to the stage-by-stage timeline of a TCPA lawsuit.

Is a class settlement the only way out?

Before a class is certified, a defendant can sometimes settle with the named plaintiff alone and skip Rule 23(e) approval. The class claims fall away without binding anyone else, and there’s no class notice or CAFA mailing to pay for. The next plaintiff can still sue. That’s why the release terms for an individual TCPA settlement matter so much.

A class settlement buys something an individual deal can’t: a release from everyone who doesn’t opt out. Scope matters. Plaintiffs often plead state mini-TCPA claims next to the federal ones, and debt collectors face companion claims under Regulation F’s limits on collection calls and texts. A release that covers only the TCPA count leaves those claims open. The release should reach every claim arising from the same calls and texts.

Trial is the other alternative, and some defendants with strong consent or autodialer defenses take it. A defendant that loses faces a judgment and then post-trial motions and appeal bonds after a TCPA verdict. That risk is why settlement structure deserves real attention while the case is still young.

When settlement talks begin

  1. Put a litigation hold on dialer, SMS platform, and CRM data for the full class period, including consent records for every number, since the class list and any claims audit will come from them.
  2. Pull the opt-out and internal do-not-call logs with dates, so the parties can tell which numbers, if any, received messages after a stop request.
  3. Gather the scrub records for the National Do Not Call Registry (the federal list of numbers whose owners opted out of telemarketing) and the version dates used, which often narrow a Do Not Call subclass.
  4. Collect vendor and lead-source contracts along with call scripts and any prerecorded or AI-voice files, and check each vendor contract for indemnity before agreeing to a fund size.
  5. Talk to a lawyer before responding to a settlement demand, agreeing to mediate, or signing a term sheet that fixes fees or the structure.

The firm’s page on defending TCPA class actions in California explains how these cases move from demand letter through class certification and settlement.

Questions defendants ask about TCPA class settlements

Is a claims-made settlement always cheaper for the defendant?

Claims-made deals usually cost less, but the Ninth Circuit reversed approval of one in 2021, so the savings can disappear at the fairness hearing. In a TCPA case, the defendant’s own records often make direct notice possible, and direct notice raises claim rates. Separately paid fees that exceed the class’s take also draw Bluetooth scrutiny. Price both structures with a realistic claim rate first.

Can a defendant agree not to oppose class counsel’s fee request?

Clear sailing provisions are allowed in the Ninth Circuit, though the 2011 Bluetooth decision called them disfavored and said they require a closer look at the fee. Briseño confirmed that the scrutiny applies after certification too. The risk is highest when the fee is paid apart from the class fund and any amount the court cuts goes back to the defendant.

Does the defendant have to notify government officials about a class settlement?

Yes, in federal court, within 10 days after the proposed settlement is filed. Each settling defendant must serve the CAFA notice on the appropriate federal and state officials. Final approval can’t issue until 90 days after the later service date. A missed mailing lets class members refuse to be bound.

Who picks the cy pres recipient?

The parties propose a recipient, and under the 2011 Nachshin decision the court approves it only if it fits the lawsuit’s claims and the interests of the class, including its geographic spread. A national privacy or consumer-telecommunications group usually fits a TCPA class better than a local charity tied to the defendant.

Negotiating a TCPA class settlement?

If your company is negotiating a TCPA class settlement, the structure of the fund and the fee terms will shape both the final cost and the approval fight. Rosenberger + Kawabata represents businesses defending TCPA lawsuits and class actions through its business litigation practice, including claims involving class settlements of call and text cases. Contact Rosenberger + Kawabata online for a confidential consultation, or call (310) 894-6921.

Sources

The settlement-approval rule is Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23, subdivision (e), as amended effective December 1, 2018. The Class Action Fairness Act provisions are 28 U.S.C. § 1712 (coupon settlements) and 28 U.S.C. § 1715 (notice to federal and state officials). The TCPA’s damages provisions are in 47 U.S.C. § 227.

The court decisions are In re Bluetooth Headset Products Liability Litigation, 654 F.3d 935 (9th Cir. 2011); Nachshin v. AOL, LLC, 663 F.3d 1034 (9th Cir. 2011); and Briseño v. Henderson, 998 F.3d 1014 (9th Cir. 2021).

This post is general information about the Telephone Consumer Protection Act and related laws as of January 31, 2026. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Courts and the FCC change the rules in this area often, and the outcome of any claim depends on its facts. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes.

← Back to Blog

Let’s Talk.