Sixth Circuit Revives Rocket Mortgage’s TCPA Arbitration Clause
On January 26, 2026, a federal appeals court told Rocket Mortgage it could push a TCPA plaintiff into arbitration because he had clicked a button on a mortgage lead site a year before the calls. The ruling reaches any company that calls or texts leads bought from a referral site. The same click that drops a consumer into a sales funnel can bind him to arbitrate and can double as his consent to be called. Companies facing these claims often hold a contract defense the demand letter never mentions.
What the Sixth Circuit decided
The court reversed a district court and ordered the dispute into arbitration. In Dahdah v. Rocket Mortgage, LLC, No. 24-1910 (6th Cir. Jan. 26, 2026), a published decision, a three-judge panel held that Michael Dahdah formed a binding arbitration agreement when he clicked buttons on LowerMyBills.com, a refinancing referral service that shares a parent company with Rocket. Applying California contract law, the court concluded that the site “gave Dahdah sufficiently conspicuous notice that he would accept the proposed terms by clicking the button.” The court reversed: “The district court thus should have granted Rocket’s motion to compel arbitration. We reverse.”
The panel was careful about the label. It called the site’s design a “hybrid offer (not a clickwrap or browsewrap offer)” because the terms sat behind a hyperlink instead of inside a box the user had to check. A true clickwrap puts the terms in front of the user and makes him click “I agree.” A browsewrap buries a link and claims the user agreed just by using the site. Dahdah’s case fell between those poles, in what some courts call a “sign-in wrap,” and that middle ground produces most of the fights.
What the clicks did reached past arbitration. The opinion noted that “if these clicks created a contract, Dahdah agreed to adhere to the Terms of Use and receive calls from LowerMyBills or an affiliate (even if he had registered on a Do Not Call registry).” The Do Not Call Registry is the national list, run through the FTC, that residential subscribers join to stop telemarketing calls. Dahdah said he had put his cellphone on it back in 2017, and he sued after Rocket called him at least eight times over four days in June 2022, some as early as 5:00 a.m. His class complaint ran under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act, 47 U.S.C. § 227.
How online contract formation worked before this ruling
Courts have sorted website agreements along a spectrum for years, and the rule itself didn’t change here. California asks whether a “reasonably prudent Internet user” would see the offer, and a hybrid proposal is enforceable only if it gives “reasonably conspicuous” notice that clicking a button accepts the terms. The leading case is the Ninth Circuit’s decision in Berman v. Freedom Financial Network, LLC, 30 F.4th 849 (9th Cir. 2022), which rejected an agreement set in “a tiny gray font” amid a cluttered page. The Sixth Circuit leaned on Berman and a line of cases from four other circuits.
One point carries weight for defendants. Under California law, when the parties don’t dispute what the website looked like, formation is a question for the judge, not the jury. The court said as much: “a court (not a jury) decides whether the undisputed website design gave reasonably conspicuous notice of the operator’s offer.” A company can win the formation issue on a motion, before the expense of a trial, as long as the screenshots aren’t in dispute.
The panel set out four questions that run through these cases. They aren’t a checklist with a passing score, because the test looks at the totality of the circumstances, but they’re the factors a business’s web design gets judged on.
| What the court asks | What helps the business | What hurts it |
|---|---|---|
| Is the page uncluttered? | A plain, simple page with little to distract from the notice | Eye-catching images and offers that pull attention away |
| Is the notice near the action button? | Notice placed directly above or below the button the user clicks | Notice sitting off to the side or below a second button |
| Does the font and color draw the eye? | A colored, contrasting hyperlink to the terms, even in small font | Small gray text with the link in the same color as everything else |
| Would the user expect an ongoing relationship? | A sign-up that implies future contact, like a lender referral | A one-off purchase a user wouldn’t expect to come with terms |
What changes for businesses that call and text, and what doesn’t
The practical change is that a company buying leads from a referral site now has a clearer arbitration path in the Sixth Circuit, even when the consumer never created an account and never signed anything. Dahdah clicked buttons labeled “Calculate” and “Calculate your FREE results,” not an “I agree” box, and he still ended up bound. The clicks were enough. The panel treated the lender-referral context as the kind of forward-looking relationship where a reasonable user expects terms to apply, a useful contrast to the one-off purchase of “a pair of socks” that the court said comes with no strings.
What doesn’t change is just as important, and this is where defense candor matters. The court called the result “a close question” and said that “LowerMyBills’ decision to use a very small font for its offer on the fourth and fifth pages provides Dahdah’s strongest counterargument.” It warned, borrowing from Judge Boggs, that companies making borderline hybrid offers create “risks” for themselves by inviting judges to second-guess the design. A design that squeaks through in one circuit can fail in another, and Michigan’s own district judges had split on this same website. Reading this ruling as a green light to keep using tiny gray disclosures would be a mistake.
The ruling also didn’t decide the TCPA merits, and that’s the quietly powerful part. Rocket’s agreement sent threshold questions to the arbitrator, not the court. The terms stated that “[a]ny controversy concerning whether a dispute is arbitrable shall be determined by the arbitrator and not by the court.” So when Dahdah argued the calls came too long after his visit, or that his consent had lapsed under a 2003 FCC order he read to cut off consent after three months, the court didn’t resolve any of it. It sent those arbitrability questions to the arbitrator and left the FCC theory undecided. A broad delegation clause is the most underused tool a defendant has in this area. A customer agreement that doesn’t delegate arbitrability hands a court the chance to decide coverage and consent-lapse arguments that an arbitrator could have taken instead.
One more point practitioners should sit with. Because the same clicks formed the arbitration agreement and captured the call consent, the record that proves consent and the record that proves the contract are usually the same set of page captures and event logs. Lose one and a company often loses both. The consent defense under the TCPA and the arbitration defense rest on the same evidence, so the preservation job is one job, not two.
The statute behind the suit is worth stating precisely, because it shapes the exposure. The Do Not Call private claim belongs only to someone who received “more than one telephone call within any 12-month period by or on behalf of the same entity,” under 47 U.S.C. § 227(c)(5), and that same subsection gives a defendant an affirmative defense for a seller that “established and implemented, with due care, reasonable practices and procedures to effectively prevent telephone solicitations” that break the rules. Damages run to “$500 in damages for each such violation” under § 227(b)(3), which a court may raise up to three times for a willful or knowing violation. None of that reaches a plaintiff whose claims get routed to arbitration first, which is why the Federal Arbitration Act’s command that arbitration agreements are “valid, irrevocable, and enforceable” does so much work in these cases.
What to do when the calls or the lead come from a referral site
A business that calls or texts purchased leads should pull the paper trail before a demand letter forces the issue.
- Preserve the page versions and screenshots of the lead site as the consumer saw them, including the look of the notice and where the buttons sat on the date he submitted, under a litigation hold once a claim arrives.
- Pull the click and event logs that show which buttons the consumer clicked and when, since those records prove both the arbitration agreement and the call consent.
- Collect the referral or lead-source contracts, the terms of use with the arbitration and delegation language, and any assignment of consent from the referral partner.
- Pull the internal do-not-call and opt-out logs and the National Do Not Call Registry scrub records, with the version dates used.
- Talk to a lawyer before answering a demand letter, calling the claimant, or offering anything to settle, because invoking arbitration too late can waive it.
A company weighing whether its customer agreement will hold up can start by reviewing where these disputes land. The firm’s TCPA defense lawyers page maps where motions to compel arbitration and Do Not Call class actions land in state and federal court. A related guide covers proving website assent against a TCPA plaintiff, and a companion post covers appealing a denied motion to compel arbitration after a court refuses to send a case out of court.
If your company is the one being sued over purchased leads
If your company bought leads from a referral site and now faces a Do Not Call or robocall claim, the site’s terms of use and your click records often decide whether the case belongs in arbitration or in court. Rosenberger + Kawabata represents businesses defending TCPA lawsuits and class actions through its business litigation practice, including claims involving leads and website consent. Contact Rosenberger + Kawabata online for a confidential consultation, or call (310) 894-6921.
Sources
The decision is Dahdah v. Rocket Mortgage, LLC, No. 24-1910 (6th Cir. Jan. 26, 2026). The statute is the Telephone Consumer Protection Act at 47 U.S.C. § 227, including the Do Not Call private right of action in § 227(c)(5) and the damages provision in § 227(b)(3). The Federal Arbitration Act makes arbitration agreements “valid, irrevocable, and enforceable” at 9 U.S.C. § 2. The court applied California contract law and the circuit precedent interpreting it, including Berman v. Freedom Financial Network, LLC, 30 F.4th 849 (9th Cir. 2022).
This post is general information about the Telephone Consumer Protection Act and related laws as of November 12, 2026. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Courts and the FCC change the rules in this area often, and the outcome of any claim depends on its facts. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes.