Waiving Arbitration Before Class Certification: Moore v. Club Exploria
Moore v. Club Exploria, LLC, decided August 18, 2026, is a Seventh Circuit TCPA case. It holds that a defendant can lose its right to arbitrate with absent class members before any class is certified. Club Exploria raised arbitration years into the case and lost it. A company with arbitration agreements covering part of a putative class has to raise them in its answer, in class discovery and in its opposition to certification. Those agreements remain one of the strongest class defenses when they’re asserted on time.
What did the Seventh Circuit decide in Moore v. Club Exploria?
The court affirmed a finding of waiver. The opinion states: “we hold that a party’s pre-certification conduct may support an inference that it waived its right to compel arbitration of putative class members’ claims.”
According to the opinion, Club Exploria hired third-party vendors in 2018 to run a prerecorded telemarketing campaign for a Florida resort. The vendors bought leads from opt-in websites. George Moore received two of the calls and sued in April 2019 on behalf of a class.
The Seventh Circuit described years of litigation before arbitration came up. The company answered with consent defenses, took part in two years of class discovery and opposed certification on consent grounds. After certification, it moved to compel arbitration against 1,026 of the 66,682 class members. It had earlier said up to 70% of the class might be covered.
Why can’t a defendant just wait until the class is certified?
Several circuits treat a motion to compel against absent class members before certification as premature. Moore accepted that point: a defendant “need not file premature motions to avoid implicit waiver of its arbitration rights.” The problem is what a defendant does in the meantime.
The court explained that “Arbitration agreements with putative class members should be produced during class-related discovery and in opposition to class certification.” Those agreements bear on the Rule 23 analysis. Litigating the class on the merits while saying nothing about them signals an intent to stay in court.
Two years of class discovery focused only on consent made the problem worse in Moore. The company had reviewed the same opt-in sites where the arbitration terms appeared, but it developed evidence of consent and not of arbitrability. Consent and arbitration often come from the same web form. Defense counsel should pull both from it at the start.
Does hiring new counsel restart the clock?
Club Exploria told the district court that new counsel had reviewed the opt-in forms and found arbitration agreements. The Seventh Circuit rejected that excuse, saying “a change in counsel late in the game cannot excuse prior counsel’s lack of diligence.”
The court added that “Four and a half years was too long for Exploria to wait to raise the topic of arbitration.” A company that switches firms mid-case should ask new counsel to audit every unasserted defense in the first weeks, arbitration first among them.
How do California federal courts treat this question?
The Ninth Circuit reached a similar result in 2023. In Hill v. Xerox Business Services, LLC, 59 F.4th 457, an employment class action, the defendant moved to compel arbitration with 2,927 class members after certification. The court held “that the district court permissibly found XBS waived this right through its specific actions and inactions over the course of years of litigation.”
Other circuits lean the other way, and Moore acknowledged the split. It cited Eighth and Eleventh Circuit decisions treating a pre-certification motion against absent members as futile. Even those cases found no waiver only where the defendant raised arbitration in its answer or certification opposition and moved quickly afterward. A defendant in California federal court should assume the Hill and Moore approach applies.
| Litigation step | What Moore treated as inconsistent with arbitration | What keeps the right intact |
|---|---|---|
| Answer | Consent defenses as to the class, no arbitration defense | An arbitration affirmative defense naming the agreements |
| Class discovery | Developing consent evidence only | Producing the arbitration terms and acceptance records |
| Class certification opposition | Arguing consent without mentioning arbitration | Arguing the agreements defeat predominance or require a narrower class |
| After certification | Merits motions and requests to reopen discovery | A prompt motion to compel once the class list is final |
Does the TCPA claim itself change the waiver analysis?
The waiver rule comes from contract law, not the TCPA. Moore relied on Morgan v. Sundance, which held that the Federal Arbitration Act makes “arbitration agreements as enforceable as other contracts, but not more so.” The FAA’s policy doesn’t give a defendant a lighter standard.
TCPA class actions raise the stakes because the damages are counted per call. 47 U.S.C. section 227(b)(3) allows $500 per violation, and a court may increase that up to $1,500 if the violation was willful or knowing. Losing the ability to move part of a class into individual arbitration can change a case’s settlement value a great deal.
What if the company already litigated without raising arbitration?
Waiver is decided on the whole record, so late is better than never. Moore reviewed the district court’s waiver finding only for clear error, which means the record before that court controls. A company in that position should raise the defense in its next pleading or brief, produce the agreements, and explain any delay with facts, not a change of lawyers.
Agreements accepted after the complaint was filed, or by class members added after certification, can stand on different footing, because the waiver question is asked group by group. A finding against older agreements doesn’t automatically reach newer ones. Defense counsel should sort the agreements by date and by source before deciding which ones to press.
What should a TCPA defendant do once a class complaint arrives?
The steps below keep both the consent defense and the arbitration defense available. In order:
- Put a litigation hold on call and text logs, dialer and platform data, and the consent records, including each lead source’s opt-in pages and terms.
- Pull the opt-out and internal do-not-call logs, with the dates each request arrived and took effect.
- Pull the National Do Not Call Registry scrub records and the version dates used for each campaign.
- Collect lead vendor contracts, the opt-in forms and their arbitration terms, call scripts, and any recorded messages.
- Talk to a lawyer before answering the complaint, contacting the named plaintiff, or offering anything to settle.
Businesses reviewing their options can see how TCPA litigation defense handles class cases from the first filing. The firm’s post on waiving arbitration after Morgan v. Sundance covers waiver against a named plaintiff. The post on forcing a TCPA class action into arbitration explains class waivers, and the post on appealing a denied motion to compel arbitration covers the stay that follows a denial.
Questions businesses ask about arbitration and absent class members
Can a defendant compel arbitration with class members before certification?
Several federal circuits treat a pre-certification motion against absent class members as premature, because they aren’t parties yet. Moore didn’t require one. What it required was notice: plead the defense, produce the agreements in class discovery, and argue them against certification. The motion itself can follow once the class is certified and the class list is final, as long as it follows promptly.
Does a waiver as to the named plaintiff waive arbitration with the whole class?
Moore cited a Sixth Circuit decision holding that waiver as to named plaintiffs “does not speak for the unnamed class members.” So a named-plaintiff waiver isn’t automatically class-wide. Each group’s waiver depends on the defendant’s conduct toward that group’s claims. Litigating class-wide consent issues for years without mentioning arbitration is the kind of conduct that reaches absent members too.
What if the arbitration agreements came from a lead vendor’s website?
In Moore, the opt-in forms came from the vendors’ sites, and the court still expected the defendant to find and assert them. A defendant relying on vendor terms has to prove assent and its own right to enforce them. That proof takes time, so the review should start with the first records request to the vendor.
Can a defendant appeal a waiver finding?
Section 16(a)(1)(B) of the Federal Arbitration Act allows an interlocutory appeal from an order denying a motion to compel arbitration. Moore also held that the Seventh Circuit reviews the ultimate waiver finding only for clear error. That deference makes the district court record decisive, so the record on diligence should be built from the first months of the case.
Defending a TCPA class action with arbitration agreements
If your company has been sued in a TCPA class action and some class members agreed to arbitrate, when and how those agreements are raised usually decides whether they can be used at all. Rosenberger + Kawabata represents businesses defending TCPA lawsuits and class actions through its business litigation practice, including claims involving arbitration agreements with putative class members. Contact Rosenberger + Kawabata online for a confidential consultation, or call (310) 894-6921.
Sources
Moore v. Club Exploria, LLC, No. 25-2721 (7th Cir. Aug. 18, 2026) (pre-certification conduct can support waiver of arbitration with putative class members).
Hill v. Xerox Business Services, LLC, 59 F.4th 457 (9th Cir. 2023) (waiver of arbitration with class members found after years of litigation).
47 U.S.C. section 227 (TCPA private right of action and damages).
This post is general information about the Telephone Consumer Protection Act and related laws as of November 17, 2026. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Courts and the FCC change the rules in this area often, and the outcome of any claim depends on its facts. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes.