Class Counsel Fees in TCPA Settlements: What Defendants Should Know
Class counsel’s fee is a common reason TCPA class settlements stall at the approval stage. That fee has to be approved by the court under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23(h), and in the Ninth Circuit a judge reviewing the deal looks hard at how the fee was negotiated, how it compares with what the class receives, and where any unawarded money goes. A defendant that structures the fee terms with that review in mind usually gets a settlement that’s approved the first time.
Who decides class counsel’s fee?
The court, even when the parties have agreed on a number. In a certified class action, “the court may award reasonable attorney’s fees and nontaxable costs that are authorized by law or by the parties’ agreement,” under Rule 23(h). The claim for fees is made by motion under Rule 54(d)(2), and notice of a motion by class counsel must be “directed to class members in a reasonable manner,” according to Rule 23(h)(1).
The court then “must find the facts and state its legal conclusions under Rule 52(a),” under Rule 23(h)(3). The fee terms also feed into whether the settlement itself is approved. Since 2018, the rule has told courts to consider “the terms of any proposed award of attorney’s fees, including timing of payment” in deciding whether the class relief is adequate, under Rule 23(e)(2)(C)(iii).
How do courts measure a reasonable fee?
By hours and rates, or by a percentage of the fund. In common-fund cases, Ninth Circuit courts may use either method, and “courts typically calculate 25% of the fund as the” benchmark, according to In re Bluetooth Headset Products Liability Litigation, 654 F.3d 935 (9th Cir. 2011). A departure from that figure needs an explanation in the record of the special circumstances that justify it.
Many TCPA settlements are claims-made deals or pay fees separately from the class fund, which makes the percentage harder to calculate. Courts don’t let structure hide the ratio. In Bluetooth, the Ninth Circuit measured the fee against what the class actually received. The district court hadn’t explained the difference, and that’s what sent the case back.
When do fee terms look collusive?
Three warning signs, which courts in the circuit call the Bluetooth factors. The first is a disproportionate fee, including “when the class receives no monetary distribution but class counsel are amply rewarded,” according to Bluetooth. The second is a clear sailing agreement, “wherein the defendant agrees not to oppose a petition for a fee award up to a specified maximum value,” according to the same opinion. The third is a kicker, where the parties arrange “for fees not awarded to revert to defendants rather than be added to the class fund.”
None of these is banned. “Although clear sailing provisions are not prohibited,” the court explained, they’re disfavored, and when a settlement has one, the district court “has a heightened duty to peer into the provision and scrutinize closely the relationship between attorneys’ fees and benefit to the class,” according to Bluetooth. Because the district court hadn’t explained why the fee was justified, the Ninth Circuit vacated the approval and fee orders and remanded.
Do the Bluetooth factors apply after a class is certified?
Yes, after the 2018 amendments. In Briseño v. Henderson, 998 F.3d 1014 (9th Cir. 2021), the court held that “courts should apply the Bluetooth factors even for post-class certification settlements.” The panel reversed approval of a consumer class settlement that had all three warning signs.
Briseño also explains why the combination worries courts. A kicker means a fee challenge “cannot increase class recovery because the excessive fees wind up back in the defendant’s pockets,” and a clear sailing clause means “the defendant has also waived its right to challenge the attorneys’ fees, foreclosing any action under Rule 23(h),” according to Briseño. With both in place, nobody is positioned to test the fee.
The court was careful about the limits of its holding. It said it didn’t seek “to make any of the identified signs of collusion an independent basis for withholding settlement approval,” and that “Disproportionate fee awards, clear sailing agreements, and kicker clauses all may be elements of a good deal,” according to Briseño. The court added that the same features can signal a collusive settlement, so district courts have to scrutinize them where they appear. What it requires is that scrutiny and an explanation, not a particular structure.
What can the defendant control?
More than most defendants expect. The fee terms are part of the settlement agreement, and the defendant negotiates them. A few choices make approval easier:
Leftover fee money that goes back to the class, or to an approved cy pres recipient, removes the kicker problem. The cy pres in TCPA settlements post covers when that’s allowed. A clear sailing clause is easier to defend when the cap is modest compared with the documented class benefit. And fee payment timed to the class’s own distribution, not shortly after approval, speaks directly to the timing factor in Rule 23(e)(2)(C)(iii).
The defendant also keeps a voice. “A class member, or a party from whom payment is sought, may object to the motion,” under Rule 23(h)(2). A defendant that hasn’t agreed to clear sailing can oppose an inflated request, and a settlement that leaves fees to the court without a promise not to object is often the cleanest path to approval. The TCPA class action settlement post covers the other terms, and the incentive awards post covers the separate payment to the named plaintiff. For how the whole deal fits into the defense of a calling case, see the firm’s TCPA class action defense page.
| Fee term | Authority | What the court asks | Lower-risk version |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fee amount | Rule 23(h); Bluetooth | How the fee compares with the value to the class | Fee near the 25% benchmark of documented class value, or hours and rates backed by records |
| Clear sailing clause | Bluetooth; Briseño | Whether the defendant traded a weaker class deal for fee peace | A modest cap, or fees left to the court |
| Kicker or reversion | Bluetooth; Briseño | Whether unawarded fees go back to the defendant | Unawarded fees go to the class or cy pres |
| Timing of payment | Rule 23(e)(2)(C)(iii) | Whether counsel is paid before the class | Payment tied to the class distribution |
| Underlying exposure | TCPA, 47 U.S.C. § 227(b)(3), (c)(5) | What the claims were worth | Up to $500 per violation, or up to $1,500 if willful or knowing |
Before agreeing to fee terms in a class settlement
- Keep the litigation hold in place over the call and text logs, dialer and platform data, and the consent records for the class numbers.
- Pull the opt-out and internal do-not-call entries for the class period, with dates, since they shape the class size and value.
- Retrieve the Do Not Call Registry scrub records and version dates that applied to the campaign.
- Gather the vendor and lead-source contracts, the scripts, and any recorded or AI-voice message files, including any indemnity terms that could shift settlement or fee costs.
- Talk to counsel before agreeing to a clear sailing cap, a reversion of unawarded fees, or a payment schedule for class counsel.
Questions about class counsel fees
Does the defendant pay class counsel’s fees separately?
It can. Some TCPA settlements pay fees out of the common fund, and others pay them on top of the class relief. Courts treat separately paid fees with care, because the money still comes from the same defendant and could have gone to the class. Either way, the court reviews the request under Rule 23(h) and weighs the fee terms in deciding whether the settlement is adequate.
Is a clear sailing agreement a reason to reject a settlement?
Not by itself. The Ninth Circuit has said clear sailing provisions aren’t prohibited, and that they can be part of a good deal. A settlement with one gets closer review, and the court has to explain why the fee is justified and doesn’t come at the class’s expense. A modest cap, and leftover fees that go to the class and not the defendant, make that explanation easier.
Can a defendant object to class counsel’s fee request?
Yes, unless it agreed not to. Rule 23(h)(2) lets a party from whom payment is sought object to the fee motion. Many settlements include a clear sailing promise that gives up that right up to a stated amount. A defendant that wants to keep the option should negotiate a settlement that leaves the fee to the court without such a promise.
What happens if the court cuts the fee?
It depends on the agreement. If unawarded fees revert to the defendant, a cut may be the very feature that draws scrutiny, and the court may question the whole deal. If the difference is added to the class fund, the settlement usually stands with a lower fee. Some agreements also provide that a fee reduction doesn’t affect approval, which helps keep the settlement intact.
Negotiating class counsel’s fee
If your company is negotiating a TCPA class settlement, the fee terms and how they compare with the class’s recovery usually decide whether the court approves it on the first try. Rosenberger + Kawabata represents businesses defending TCPA lawsuits and class actions through its business litigation practice, including claims involving class settlement and fee negotiations. Contact Rosenberger + Kawabata online for a confidential consultation, or call (310) 894-6921.
Sources
The fee and settlement rules are in Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23. The Ninth Circuit decisions are In re Bluetooth Headset Products Liability Litigation, 654 F.3d 935 (9th Cir. 2011), and Briseño v. Henderson, 998 F.3d 1014 (9th Cir. 2021). The federal calling statute is 47 U.S.C. § 227.
Related TCPA defense topics
- Sanctions Against TCPA Plaintiffs
This post is general information about the Telephone Consumer Protection Act and related laws as of September 27, 2026. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Courts and the FCC change the rules in this area often, and the outcome of any claim depends on its facts. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes.