Coupon and Voucher Settlements in TCPA Class Actions Under CAFA

Vouchers look cheap to a defendant settling a TCPA class action, and sometimes they are. But a settlement that pays the class in coupons falls under 28 U.S.C. § 1712, part of the Class Action Fairness Act, which ties class counsel’s fee to the value of coupons actually redeemed and requires a hearing and written finding before approval. That changes how plaintiffs’ counsel negotiates and how long approval takes. A defendant that knows where the coupon line sits can often design relief that serves its business without triggering those rules.

What does CAFA say about coupon settlements?

It limits how class counsel gets paid, and it adds a layer of court review. If a settlement “provides for a recovery of coupons to a class member, the portion of any attorney’s fee award to class counsel that is attributable to the award of the coupons shall be based on the value to class members of the coupons that are redeemed,” under 28 U.S.C. § 1712(a).

If the coupons aren’t used to measure the fee, the fee “shall be based upon the amount of time class counsel reasonably expended working on the action,” under § 1712(b)(1). Either way, the court “may approve the proposed settlement only after a hearing to determine whether, and making a written finding that, the settlement is fair, reasonable, and adequate for class members,” under § 1712(e).

The statute also lets a court, on a party’s motion, hear expert testimony “on the actual value to the class members of the coupons that are redeemed,” under § 1712(d). And it allows the court to require, as agreed to by the parties, that part of the value of unclaimed coupons go to charitable or governmental organizations. The cy pres in TCPA settlements post covers how courts review those distributions.

Is a voucher or gift card a coupon?

It depends on how it works. CAFA doesn’t define “coupon,” so courts look at the features of the award. The leading Ninth Circuit case is In re Online DVD-Rental Antitrust Litigation, 779 F.3d 934 (9th Cir. 2015). The court held that $12 retailer gift cards weren’t coupons, and it affirmed the settlement and the fee.

The court explained what separates a coupon from something closer to cash. Discounts of the kind Congress targeted “require class members to hand over more of their own money before they can take advantage of the coupon, and they often are only valid for select products or services,” according to Online DVD. The gift cards there were different: “The class member need not spend any of his or her own money and can choose from a large number of potential items to purchase.”

The district court in that case had also relied on the fact that claimants could take cash over a card, that the cards were freely transferable, and that they didn’t expire, according to the Ninth Circuit’s opinion. Those are the design levers. A credit good only for the defendant’s own services, with an expiration date and a minimum purchase, looks like a coupon. A no-strings card or a cash option usually doesn’t.

How are fees calculated when a settlement mixes coupons and other relief?

In two parts. In re HP Inkjet Printer Litigation, 716 F.3d 1173 (9th Cir. 2013), sets out the method. The court first sets a fee for the coupon portion based on “the actual redemption value of the coupons awarded,” according to the opinion. It then sets a separate fee for any non-coupon relief, such as an injunction, based on the hours class counsel reasonably worked.

The district court there had awarded an hours-based fee, cut to match its rough estimate of the settlement’s overall value, without first working out the coupons’ redemption value. The Ninth Circuit held that a court may not award fees “attributable to” coupons “without first considering the redemption value of the coupons,” and it reversed the approval and fee orders and remanded, according to HP Inkjet.

Why does the settlement structure matter to the defendant?

Because a badly built coupon deal can unravel after approval. The court in HP Inkjet put much of the blame on the deal itself: “the responsibility for this error lies principally with the parties,” it wrote, because the agreement provided that no coupons could issue until after final judgment, which made it impossible to measure redemption before fees were set, according to HP Inkjet. “By structuring the settlement in this way, the parties essentially invited the error here.”

For a TCPA defendant, the practical lesson is to decide early whether coupon relief is worth it. Credits appeal to businesses for good reasons. They cost less than cash when many go unused, they bring customers back, and they can be paired with changes to the calling program that the business planned to make anyway. Those same features are what draw objectors. A credit that’s worth little to most of the class, paired with a large fee, is the kind of settlement the statute was written to police, and courts look hard at the record when they see one. Class counsel paid on redemption has every reason to push for cash or a high-value credit, and a coupon deal can mean a delayed fee ruling, a second hearing, or an appeal by an objector. A business that wants to offer service credits should build in a cash option or a claims period that ends before the fee motion, so the court can see real redemption numbers. The CAFA notice post covers the separate notice CAFA requires for every class settlement, and the TCPA class settlement post covers the other terms. For how settlement fits into the broader defense of a calling case, see the firm’s TCPA settlement defense page.

Relief type Authority How class counsel’s fee is measured Approval risk
Coupons or discounts on the defendant’s services 28 U.S.C. § 1712(a), (e) Value of coupons actually redeemed Hearing and written finding required, plus objector focus
Coupons plus injunctive relief § 1712(c); HP Inkjet Redemption value for the coupon part, hours and rates for the rest Fee ruling may wait for redemption data
Cash, or gift cards with a cash option and no expiration Online DVD Ordinary Rule 23(h) review Lower, if the value is real
The underlying TCPA claims 47 U.S.C. § 227(b)(3), (c)(5) Not applicable Up to $500 per violation, or up to $1,500 if willful or knowing

Before offering vouchers to settle a class action

  1. Keep the litigation hold in place over the call and text logs, dialer and platform data, and the consent records for the class numbers.
  2. Pull the opt-out and internal do-not-call entries for the class period, with dates.
  3. Retrieve the Do Not Call Registry scrub records and version dates that applied to the campaign.
  4. Gather the vendor and lead-source contracts and scripts, the recorded or AI-voice message files, and the data needed to estimate how many class members would redeem a credit.
  5. Talk to counsel before proposing coupon or credit relief, a claims process, or a fee structure to class counsel.

Questions about coupon settlements

Does CAFA ban coupon settlements?

No. CAFA allows them but adds conditions. Class counsel’s fee for the coupon portion has to be based on the value of coupons actually redeemed, and the court can approve the deal only after a hearing and a written finding that it meets the statute’s fairness standard for class members. Those conditions make coupon deals slower and less attractive to class counsel, which affects negotiation.

Is an account credit for the defendant’s own service a coupon?

Often, yes. Credits usable only with the defendant, and more so ones that expire or require another purchase, resemble the discounts Congress targeted. The Ninth Circuit has pointed to whether class members must spend their own money and whether the award is limited to select products. A credit that can be taken as cash, or that works like a general gift card, is less likely to be treated as a coupon.

Can a defendant’s expert testify about coupon value?

Yes. The statute allows the court, on a party’s motion, to receive expert testimony on the actual value to class members of the coupons that are redeemed. Defendants sometimes use redemption data from past promotions to show realistic redemption rates, which can affect both the fee and the court’s view of the settlement’s value.

Do coupon rules apply in state court TCPA cases?

Section 1712 is part of the federal code and governs class actions in federal court. TCPA class actions can be filed in state court, and state class action rules differ. Many defendants remove these cases to federal court when they can, which brings CAFA’s coupon provisions along with it.

Settling a TCPA class action on credits or vouchers

If your company is weighing service credits or vouchers to settle a TCPA class action, the redemption structure and the fee terms usually decide whether the court approves it. Rosenberger + Kawabata represents businesses defending TCPA lawsuits and class actions through its business litigation practice, including claims involving coupon and credit settlements. Contact Rosenberger + Kawabata online for a confidential consultation, or call (310) 894-6921.

Sources

The coupon settlement statute is 28 U.S.C. § 1712. The Ninth Circuit decisions are In re HP Inkjet Printer Litigation, 716 F.3d 1173 (9th Cir. 2013), and In re Online DVD-Rental Antitrust Litigation, 779 F.3d 934 (9th Cir. 2015). The federal calling statute is 47 U.S.C. § 227.

This post is general information about the Telephone Consumer Protection Act and related laws as of September 30, 2026. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Courts and the FCC change the rules in this area often, and the outcome of any claim depends on its facts. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes.

← Back to Blog

Let’s Talk.