Should You Move to Dismiss a TCPA Case for Lack of Standing?

A standing defense is one of the few motions that can end a TCPA case before discovery, but it works only on the right facts. The question under Article III isn’t whether the company broke the statute. It’s whether the plaintiff was actually injured. Most people who sue over calls and texts did get them, and the Supreme Court treats that intrusion as a concrete harm. So the sharper play is usually narrower: shrink the damages class, or move the case to a court the defense prefers.

When does a TCPA plaintiff have standing to sue?

When the plaintiff can show a concrete injury from the call or text, not just a rule broken on paper.

Article III limits federal courts to real disputes, so a plaintiff in federal court has to show an injury that’s concrete and not hypothetical. The Supreme Court said so directly in Spokeo, Inc. v. Robins: “Article III standing requires a concrete injury even in the context of a statutory violation.” A company can break a rule without hurting anyone, and when that happens the plaintiff is out of federal court. A plaintiff can’t rely on “a bare procedural violation, divorced from any concrete harm” to get through the door.

Five years later, TransUnion LLC v. Ramirez tightened the test to four words: “No concrete harm, no standing.” The Court explained that an intangible harm still counts when it has a “close relationship” to a harm courts have long recognized. Unwanted calls and texts usually clear that bar, because they resemble the old privacy tort of intrusion upon seclusion. That’s why a flat no-injury attack on a plaintiff who got real calls tends to fail. An earlier post on whether one text or call can get a case dismissed covers how courts treat the single-contact plaintiff.

What does a no-injury standing motion actually get you?

On the right facts, dismissal. More often, a smaller class or a better forum.

Outright dismissal is the exception, and it shows up where the alleged violation didn’t involve an unwanted contact at all. Think of a plaintiff who consented to the call but sues over a recordkeeping or disclosure defect that caused no harm, or one who alleges only a risk of future calls. Those are the theories Spokeo and TransUnion were built to knock out. If the complaint is really about a call the plaintiff asked for and a paperwork slip that changed nothing, the motion can win.

The more common payoff is a smaller class. TransUnion held that “Every class member must have Article III standing in order to recover individual damages.” The Court applied that rule to its own facts and split the class in two: the roughly 1,853 members whose misleading credit files were sent to third parties could recover, and the roughly 6,332 whose files were never disseminated could not, because nothing happened to them. A TCPA class works the same way. Members who never received the call, whose numbers were wrong numbers, or whose phones never rang may have no injury to show, and sorting out who was actually harmed can swamp the common questions a class action needs.

That leaves the third use, which is the one defendants forget.

Can winning on standing send the case to state court?

Yes, and that’s the trap.

A dismissal for lack of Article III standing is jurisdictional, which means it’s without prejudice. The plaintiff doesn’t lose the claim. The plaintiff loses the courthouse. And state courts don’t answer to Article III. As the Supreme Court put it in Asarco Inc. v. Kadish, “the constraints of Article III do not apply to state courts,” so a state court can hear a case a federal court couldn’t. Many state courts let a TCPA plaintiff sue without the concrete-injury showing TransUnion demands.

So the no-injury motion can backfire. If your company removed the case to federal court to get the benefit of federal class-action rules, a plaintiff can defeat the removal by arguing its own lack of standing and asking for a remand. Win the standing fight and you may hand the plaintiff a state forum with looser rules and a jury pool you didn’t pick. The honest read is that standing cuts both ways, and sometimes a defendant is better off with a plaintiff who has standing, because that keeps the case in federal court where the predominance rule and removal statutes favor the defense.

Reflexive motion practice trips over a simple fact. In most TCPA cases the plaintiff got a real call or text, and TransUnion says that kind of intrusion counts. Filing a motion that argues no injury on those facts rarely wins, and it teaches the plaintiff’s lawyer exactly how to replead. Save the frontal standing attack for the injury-free case. Everywhere else, use standing to shape the class and the forum, not to swing for a dismissal you won’t get.

Claim theory Statute Per-violation exposure The standing question
Unconsented robocall, prerecorded call, or text to a cell phone § 227(b)(3) $500, and up to $1,500 if the violation was willful or knowing Usually met: an unwanted call or text looks like the privacy intrusion TransUnion recognized
Do Not Call violation, more than one call in 12 months § 227(c)(5) up to $500, and up to three times that if willful or knowing Usually met for the calls themselves, though the statute’s reasonable-procedures defense is a separate fight
Procedural or recordkeeping defect with no unwanted contact § 227 and the FCC rules same caps Weakest for the plaintiff: Spokeo says a bare procedural violation with no concrete harm isn’t an injury

The damages numbers are exposure the business faces, not an amount any plaintiff is sure to recover. Note the wording gap the statute draws: § 227(b)(3) sets damages at “$500 in damages for each such violation,” while the Do Not Call provision says “up to $500,” and a court may treble either one only if it finds the violation willful or knowing.

What to do when a TCPA claim lands

Standing arguments are built from the call records, so the first job is keeping those records intact. Once a demand letter or complaint arrives:

  1. Put a litigation hold on the call and text logs, the dialer and platform data, and the consent records for every number in the case, before anything gets purged on a routine retention schedule.
  2. Pull the opt-out and internal do-not-call logs with their dates, so you can see which numbers asked to stop and when.
  3. Pull the National Do Not Call Registry scrub records and the version dates the campaign ran against.
  4. Gather the vendor and lead-source contracts, the call and text scripts, and any recorded or prerecorded message files.
  5. Talk to a lawyer before you answer a demand letter, reach out to the plaintiff, or offer anything to settle, because an early admission can cost you a defense you didn’t know you had.

Whether a no-injury motion helps or hurts is a case-by-case call, and it rides on facts most companies haven’t pulled together yet when the letter arrives. The firm’s TCPA litigation defense page walks through how these motions and class actions move through federal and state court. A post on uninjured class members after the Labcorp dismissal goes deeper on the class-shrinking side of the argument.

If your company is the one being sued

If your company is facing a TCPA class action, whether the plaintiff and the absent class members can show a real injury often decides how large the case ever gets.

Rosenberger + Kawabata represents businesses defending TCPA lawsuits and class actions through its business litigation practice, including claims that turn on Article III standing and uninjured class members. Contact Rosenberger + Kawabata online for a confidential consultation, or call (310) 894-6921.

Questions companies ask about TCPA standing

Does a wrong-number call still give the plaintiff standing?

If the plaintiff actually received the call, usually yes, and the real dispute shifts to consent or whether the number was the plaintiff’s. The standing question gets sharp for a class, where absent members may include people whose numbers were reassigned or who never got the call at all. After TransUnion, those uninjured members can’t recover, which is where a defendant pries the class apart.

Is a standing dismissal with or without prejudice?

A dismissal for lack of Article III standing is jurisdictional, so it’s without prejudice. The federal court isn’t ruling that the claim is bad. It’s ruling that it has no power to hear it. The plaintiff can refile, and because state courts aren’t bound by Article III, the refiling often lands in state court under rules that don’t require the same injury showing.

Can a single unwanted text ever be too minor to sue over?

Not on that theory alone. No federal appeals court still treats one unwanted text as too trivial to count, and courts generally find the intrusion concrete enough for standing. The stronger defenses to a one-text case are consent and, in a class action, the standing of the absent members, not the named plaintiff’s single message.

Should every TCPA answer raise lack of standing?

Preserve it, yes, because standing can be raised at any stage and it drives class certification later. Filing a no-injury motion to dismiss is a different decision. On a plaintiff who got real calls, that motion usually loses and only sharpens the amended complaint, so the question is whether the facts give you a genuine injury-free theory or a reason to want the case out of federal court.

Sources

47 U.S.C. § 227, the private right of action and damages, including the reasonable-procedures affirmative defense in § 227(c)(5).

Spokeo, Inc. v. Robins, 578 U.S. 330 (2016).

TransUnion LLC v. Ramirez, 594 U.S. 413 (2021).

Asarco Inc. v. Kadish, 490 U.S. 605 (1989).

This post is general information about the Telephone Consumer Protection Act and related laws as of August 24, 2026. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Courts and the FCC change the rules in this area often, and the outcome of any claim depends on its facts. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes.

← Back to Blog

Let’s Talk.