A company sued over calls to purchased leads often finds an arbitration clause in the lead site’s terms, then learns it never signed them. That doesn’t end the argument. State contract law lets a nonparty enforce an arbitration clause in limited ways, and a seller named in the terms or acting through an agent may qualify. California’s high court narrowed one route in 2025, and the safest path is now the one built into the contract before the calls began.
Can a company that didn’t sign the terms compel arbitration?
Section 3 of the Federal Arbitration Act is open to a nonparty if state contract law gives it a way in. In Arthur Andersen LLP v. Carlisle, 556 U.S. 624 (2009), the Supreme Court held that “a litigant who was not a party to the relevant arbitration agreement may invoke §3 if the relevant state contract law allows him to enforce the agreement.” Section 3 is the provision that stays a lawsuit pending arbitration.
The Arthur Andersen opinion listed the doctrines that can carry a contract to a nonparty: “assumption, piercing the corporate veil, alter ego, incorporation by reference, third-party beneficiary theories, waiver and estoppel.” The Federal Arbitration Act doesn’t create these routes. They come from state law, so a California seller’s answer comes from California contract doctrine.
A TCPA claim arises under 47 U.S.C. § 227, a federal statute, but the question of who may enforce the lead site’s arbitration clause is a state-law contract question. The choice-of-law clause in the terms, if there is one, usually tells the court which state’s doctrine applies.
What did the California Supreme Court decide in 2025?
The California Supreme Court held in July 2025 that a nonsignatory can’t use equitable estoppel when the plaintiff’s claims rest on statutory duties, not the contract. In Ford Motor Warranty Cases (S279969), buyers sued Ford, not the dealers whose sales contracts held the arbitration clause. Ford argued the buyers’ claims were close enough to those contracts that they should be estopped from avoiding arbitration.
The court rejected that argument: “As plaintiffs’ claims are not intimately founded in or intertwined with the sales contracts, plaintiffs should not be estopped from pursuing their remedies against Ford in court.” The plaintiffs’ claims flowed “from obligations imposed by statute or conventional fraud duties,” in the court’s words, and the sales contracts didn’t create those duties.
TCPA claims look a lot like the Song-Beverly Act claims in Ford. The duty not to call a cell phone with an artificial voice without consent comes from section 227(b), not from the lead site’s terms. A plaintiff suing the seller for unwanted calls usually isn’t enforcing anything in those terms. Under Ford, an estoppel argument built on the lead site’s contract will face a hard road in California courts.
The court also restated the baseline: “The general rule is that one must be a party to an arbitration agreement either to be bound by or to invoke it.” Every nonsignatory theory is an exception to that rule, and courts read exceptions narrowly.
Which routes still work for a seller?
Agency and third-party beneficiary status are the two routes most likely to work, and both depend on facts the seller can document. Ford Motor Warranty Cases pointed to agency directly: “Had the dealerships acted as Ford’s agents when selling the cars, Ford could argue it had a right to invoke the arbitration clause in the sales contracts entered into by its agents.” Ford lost on that point only because the buyers alleged no agency.
TCPA plaintiffs often allege agency themselves under section 227. A complaint that targets the seller for a vendor’s calls has to plead that the vendor acted for the seller. The firm’s post on when a seller is liable for a vendor’s calls covers that theory. A seller can sometimes turn that allegation into an arbitration argument. A plaintiff who says the caller was the seller’s agent will find it hard to argue the seller can’t invoke the agent’s contract.
Goonewardene v. ADP, LLC (2019) 6 Cal.5th 817 sets out the second route, third-party beneficiary status. The California Supreme Court required a court to examine “(1) whether the third party would in fact benefit from the contract, but also (2) whether a motivating purpose of the contracting parties was to provide a benefit to the third party, and (3) whether permitting a third party to bring its own breach of contract action against a contracting party is consistent with the objectives of the contract and the reasonable expectations of the contracting parties.”
Lead site terms that name the buyers, or that define marketing partners in a way that reaches the seller by name, give the seller something to work with under Goonewardene. Terms that mention third parties in general and never identify the seller give it much less. A seller that buys leads should read the terms for its own name before it reads anything else.
How does this play out with lead generators and affiliates?
Corporate family ties make the strongest case, and the Dahdah decision is the recent example. Rocket Mortgage enforced terms on a referral site run by a company sharing its parent, after the Sixth Circuit found the consumer had agreed to them. Affiliates and corporate siblings named in the terms are the easiest nonsignatories to fit within the clause.
Ford Motor Warranty Cases leaves an unrelated lead buyer in a weaker spot. It usually has a lead purchase agreement with the generator, but the consumer never saw that contract, and it doesn’t bind the consumer. The buyer’s right to arbitrate depends on the consumer-facing terms and on whether those terms name the buyer, cover it as an agent, or reach it some other way state law accepts.
| Theory | What the seller must show | How it usually fares in a TCPA case |
|---|---|---|
| Party or named affiliate | The terms name the seller or its corporate family | Strongest route, and the fight shifts to whether the consumer agreed |
| Agency | The signatory acted as the seller’s agent | Often available, because TCPA plaintiffs plead agency to reach the seller |
| Third-party beneficiary | A motivating purpose of the terms was to benefit the seller | Works when the terms identify the seller, but weak with generic “partners” language |
| Equitable estoppel | The claims are intimately founded in the contract | Weak in California after Ford, because TCPA duties come from the statute |
Does the arbitrator or the court decide who can enforce the clause?
Under the Federal Arbitration Act, a motion to compel goes to a judge, who usually decides who can enforce the clause unless the clause expressly delegates that question. A delegation clause sends questions about the clause’s reach to the arbitrator, and the firm’s post on class waivers and TCPA arbitration explains how they operate. A nonsignatory relying on a delegation clause should expect the plaintiff to argue that a court, not the arbitrator, decides whether the nonsignatory can use the clause at all.
Lead site terms drafted before the first campaign can name the buyers, include their agents and affiliates, and delegate arbitrability. That gives a later defendant three arguments instead of one, so the drafting matters more than the litigation. Sellers negotiating lead purchase agreements can ask for exactly that language, and they should.
What should a seller collect before moving to compel arbitration?
A seller that wants to compel arbitration of a TCPA claim it never signed for should collect these records first:
- Put a litigation hold on the call and text logs, dialer and platform data, and the consent records for the plaintiff’s number.
- Pull the opt-out and internal do-not-call records for the number, with dates.
- Pull the Do Not Call Registry scrub records and the version dates used for the campaign.
- Collect the lead site’s terms as they stood on the sign-up date, the lead purchase agreement, any vendor contracts, and the call scripts or recorded messages.
- Talk to a lawyer before responding to a demand letter, contacting the claimant, or offering anything to settle.
The Morgan v. Sundance waiver rule means litigating the merits before moving to compel can cost the right, so the timing deserves care. Companies weighing that choice often consult TCPA defense attorneys in California before filing a first response.
Questions businesses ask about nonsignatory arbitration
Can a lead buyer enforce a lead generator’s arbitration clause?
A lead buyer can enforce the clause only if state law gives it a route, and the terms themselves usually decide which route exists. Terms naming the buyer or its corporate family make a party or beneficiary argument possible. Agency is another option when the plaintiff alleges the generator called for the buyer. Without any of those, a buyer in California faces the general rule that only parties may invoke an arbitration agreement.
Does equitable estoppel still work in California TCPA cases?
Ford Motor Warranty Cases made it much harder. The court applied estoppel only where the plaintiff’s claims are intimately founded in and intertwined with the contract. TCPA claims rest on statutory duties, so the argument rarely fits. A seller relying on estoppel alone should expect to lose the motion and should look first for a party, agency, or beneficiary theory that does fit.
What if the terms only mention “marketing partners”?
Goonewardene makes generic partner language a weak hook. Under that case, the seller has to show that benefiting it was a motivating purpose of the contract, not just a side effect. A defined list of partners, a link to a named partner page, or the seller’s name in the consent language all help. A seller buying leads should check that list for its own name before the first campaign.
Can a seller lose the right to arbitrate by waiting?
Yes, and the 2022 rule applies to a nonsignatory’s right just as it does to a signatory’s. Litigating the merits before moving to compel can lead a court to find waiver. In Morgan v. Sundance, Inc. (2022) 596 U.S. 411, the Supreme Court held that federal courts can’t require the plaintiff to show prejudice. A seller that thinks it has an arbitration argument should raise it at the start of the case, before discovery.
If your company is the one being sued over purchased leads
If your company is sued over calls or texts to leads it bought, the lead site’s terms and the relationship with the generator often decide whether the case belongs in arbitration. Rosenberger + Kawabata represents businesses defending TCPA lawsuits and class actions through its business litigation practice, including claims involving calls and texts to purchased leads. Contact Rosenberger + Kawabata online for a confidential consultation, or call (310) 894-6921.
Sources
Arthur Andersen LLP v. Carlisle (2009) 556 U.S. 624 (nonparties may invoke FAA section 3 when state contract law allows).
Ford Motor Warranty Cases (Cal. July 3, 2025, S279969) (equitable estoppel limited to claims intimately founded in the contract; agency route).
Goonewardene v. ADP, LLC (2019) 6 Cal.5th 817 (three-part third-party beneficiary test).
47 U.S.C. section 227 (TCPA restrictions and private rights of action).
9 U.S.C. section 2 (written arbitration agreements enforceable).
Morgan v. Sundance, Inc. (2022) 596 U.S. 411 (no prejudice requirement for waiver of arbitration).
This post is general information about the Telephone Consumer Protection Act and related laws as of November 15, 2026. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Courts and the FCC change the rules in this area often, and the outcome of any claim depends on its facts. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes.